Psychoanalytic Criticism

Psychoanalytic criticism reads literature through the lens of the unconscious mind. It argues that literary texts — like dreams — are shaped by desires, anxieties, and conflicts that operate beneath the surface of conscious intention. For A-Level, psychoanalytic concepts provide powerful tools for analysing character, motivation, imagery, and the reader's emotional response.

---

Sigmund Freud (1856–1939)

Freud did not write literary criticism in the academic sense, but his theories of the mind have had an incalculable influence on how we read literature. The key concepts you need to know are:

1. The Structure of the Psyche

Component	Function	Literary Application
Id	The unconscious reservoir of instinctual drives — sex (Eros) and aggression (Thanatos). It operates on the "pleasure principle" — seeking immediate gratification	Characters driven by desire, violence, or compulsion — Heathcliff, Iago, Stanley Kowalski
Ego	The conscious, rational self that mediates between the id's demands and reality. It operates on the "reality principle"	Characters who calculate, strategise, and compromise — Pip, Nick Carraway
Superego	The internalised moral authority — conscience, guilt, the parental "voice" that says "you should" and "you must not"	Characters tormented by guilt or moral obligation — Hamlet, Angel Clare, the narrator of Spies

Application: In Othello, Iago can be read as Othello's id — the voice of his repressed jealousy and sexual anxiety. Othello's tragedy is that he cannot resist the id's demands; his superego (his honour, his self-image as a noble Moor) is overwhelmed by unconscious forces he cannot control.

2. The Oedipus Complex

Definition: Freud argued that in early childhood, the child desires the parent of the opposite sex and sees the same-sex parent as a rival. The resolution of this conflict — through identification with the same-sex parent — is the foundation of adult identity.

Application: Hamlet's delay in killing Claudius has been explained by Ernest Jones (in Hamlet and Oedipus, 1949) as an Oedipal paralysis: Hamlet cannot kill Claudius because Claudius has done what Hamlet himself unconsciously desired — killed his father and married his mother. Claudius is not Hamlet's enemy but his unconscious double.

A-Level Caution: The Oedipal reading of Hamlet is influential but controversial. Use it as one interpretation among several, not as the definitive answer.

3. The Uncanny (Das Unheimliche)

Definition: Freud's concept (1919) of the "uncanny" — the feeling of unease produced by something that is simultaneously familiar and strange. The uncanny arises when something repressed returns in an unexpected form.

Application: Gothic literature is rich in the uncanny — doubles, ghosts, haunted houses, the return of the dead. In Spies, the childhood memories that return to old Stephen are uncanny in Freud's sense: familiar yet distorted, comforting yet disturbing.

4. Repression and the Return of the Repressed

Definition: Repression is the unconscious mechanism by which unacceptable desires, memories, and thoughts are pushed out of consciousness. But repressed material does not disappear — it returns in disguised forms: dreams, symptoms, slips of the tongue, and — crucially — literature.

Application: In Waterland, Tom Crick's compulsive storytelling can be read as the return of repressed trauma. He cannot stop telling the story of his past because the past — the death of Freddie Parr, Mary's abortion, Dick's incestuous origins — has been repressed and is forcing its way back into consciousness.

5. Dreams and Symbolism

Freud argued that dreams are the "royal road to the unconscious." Dreams use symbolic language — condensation (combining multiple meanings into a single image) and displacement (transferring emotional significance from one object to another) — that literature also employs.

Application: The paper lantern in A Streetcar Named Desire operates like a dream symbol. On the surface, it softens the light; symbolically, it represents Blanche's desire to hide from reality, her need for illusion, and her fragile attempt to beautify an ugly world. The destruction of the lantern by Stanley is both a literal and a symbolic act of violence.

---

Jacques Lacan (1901–1981)

Lacan reinterpreted Freud through the lens of structural linguistics and philosophy. His ideas are notoriously difficult, but two concepts are particularly useful for A-Level:

1. The Mirror Stage