You are viewing a free preview of this lesson.
Subscribe to unlock all 10 lessons in this course and every other course on LearningBro.
Thomas Hardy's "At an Inn" is one of the most psychologically complex poems in the Pre-1900 Love Poetry Anthology. Where "The Ruined Maid" uses irony to expose social hypocrisy, "At an Inn" turns irony inward — exploring the gap between appearance and reality, between what the world sees and what the lovers feel, between desire and the constraints that prevent its fulfilment.
AO3 — Context: The poem is believed to have been inspired by a visit Hardy made to an inn with Florence Henniker in 1893. Henniker was a writer and society figure with whom Hardy was deeply (and probably unrequitedly) in love. They were observed together at the inn and assumed by the staff to be lovers — an assumption that was, according to Hardy, painfully untrue. Hardy was married to his first wife, Emma, at the time; the marriage was unhappy, but Hardy's emotional attachments to other women were constrained by social convention, his public reputation, and — in Henniker's case — her unwillingness to enter a physical relationship.
Hardy's pessimistic worldview was shaped by his reading of Schopenhauer (who argued that desire is the source of all suffering) and by Darwin (whose theory of natural selection suggested a universe indifferent to human happiness). Love, in Hardy's view, is subject to the same cruel ironies as everything else: the people who want each other cannot have each other; the people who have each other no longer want each other.
The poem consists of seven stanzas of six lines each, rhyming ABABCC. The regular form and the closed couplet at the end of each stanza create a sense of containment — appropriate for a poem about feelings that cannot be expressed or acted upon. The poem's structure moves between two perspectives: the public world (what others see) and the private world (what the speakers feel).
"When we as strangers sought / Their catering care, / Veiled smiles bespoke their thought / Of what we were. / They warmed as they opined / Us more than friends —"
The opening establishes the central irony. The two travellers arrive at the inn "as strangers" — that is, they are not lovers. But the inn staff read their body language and conclude otherwise. "Veiled smiles" and "opined" suggest knowing, conspiratorial amusement — the staff think they are witnessing an illicit liaison.
"And we were. And yet were not. — / But such their view, / The common world of thought / So rated us two."
The parenthetical interruption — "And we were. And yet were not." — is one of the most poignant lines in Hardy's poetry. They are more than friends in feeling, but they are not more than friends in fact. The dash after "not" creates a pause that enacts the gap between desire and reality. "The common world of thought" frames public opinion as shallow and presumptuous — the world sees surfaces and draws conclusions.
"And cogitating thus, / They mused and said: / 'Ah, yes! our best room was / For such as they.' / A double room was given, / And so, unsought, / We found the thing we'd not / Have dared to pray."
The staff, assuming the pair are lovers, give them a double room. The irony is excruciating: the room offers the physical intimacy that the speakers desire but cannot allow themselves. "Unsought" and "not have dared to pray" reveal the depth of the unfulfilled desire — they would not even have dared to wish for this proximity. The words "pray" and "dared" suggest that the desire is not merely socially forbidden but feels morally transgressive.
"Yet on our part was cold restraint — / No tender word or sign — / For others seemed to us to paint / Our look as lovers' line."
Despite the private opportunity, the speakers maintain "cold restraint." The awareness that they are being watched — that "others seemed to us to paint / Our look as lovers' line" — intensifies their self-consciousness. They cannot enjoy even the appearance of intimacy because they know the appearance is being read as evidence. The observers' gaze becomes a surveillance that polices their behaviour.
"And we were left alone / As Love's own pair; / Yet never the love-Loss known / Was felt so bare!"
The paradox is crystallised: they are treated as lovers, given the space and privacy that lovers need, and yet the experience only intensifies their awareness of what they cannot have. "Love-Loss" — Hardy's characteristic compound — suggests both the loss of love and the love that is defined by loss. "So bare" implies nakedness, vulnerability, exposure — the feeling of being stripped of defences.
Subscribe to continue reading
Get full access to this lesson and all 10 lessons in this course.