Britain and the Second World War 1939–1945

The Second World War is often described as Britain's "finest hour" — a narrative of national unity, stoic endurance, and collective sacrifice. While this narrative captures something real about the wartime experience, historians have increasingly complicated the picture, revealing social tensions, class conflict, and the war's uneven impact. This lesson examines the political, social, and economic dimensions of the war — and analyses the extent to which the war created the conditions for the post-war welfare state.

---

The Political War

From Chamberlain to Churchill (September 1939 – May 1940)

Neville Chamberlain led Britain into war but proved an uninspiring war leader. The disastrous Norway Campaign (April 1940) precipitated a parliamentary crisis.

Event	Detail
Norway Debate (7–8 May 1940)	Leo Amery quoted Cromwell to Chamberlain: "In the name of God, go!" The government's majority fell from over 200 to 81 — a devastating political blow
Churchill becomes PM (10 May 1940)	Churchill formed a genuinely national Coalition government with Labour (Attlee as Deputy PM, Bevin as Minister of Labour, Morrison as Home Secretary) and the Liberals
Churchill's leadership	His rhetorical genius ("We shall fight on the beaches...") provided inspirational leadership, but his strategic judgement was sometimes questionable and his relationship with Labour was often tense

Labour in Government

Labour's participation in the wartime Coalition was transformative for the party. Labour ministers gained governmental experience, credibility, and influence over domestic policy.

Minister	Role	Significance
Clement Attlee	Deputy Prime Minister; chaired the Cabinet's domestic committees	Gained experience and authority that prepared him for the premiership
Ernest Bevin	Minister of Labour and National Service	Managed the wartime labour force with remarkable effectiveness; became the most powerful trade unionist in British history
Herbert Morrison	Home Secretary	Managed civil defence and the home front
Hugh Dalton	Board of Trade; then Minister of Economic Warfare	Developed economic planning expertise

---

The Home Front

Total War and State Intervention

The Second World War demanded total mobilisation of the economy and society. The state's role expanded far beyond anything attempted in 1914–1918.

Area	Intervention
Conscription	National Service (Armed Forces) Act (September 1939) — all men aged 18–41 liable for military service; extended to women in December 1941 (the National Service Act No. 2)
Industry	The Essential Work Order (1941) directed workers to essential industries; strikes were made illegal (though they continued)
Food	Rationing began in January 1940 (bacon, butter, sugar) and was progressively extended; the "Dig for Victory" campaign; British Restaurants provided communal meals
Evacuation	Approximately 1.5 million children evacuated from cities in September 1939; the experience exposed the extent of urban poverty and poor health, shocking middle-class hosts
Bombing	The Blitz (September 1940 – May 1941) killed approximately 43,000 civilians; later V-1 and V-2 attacks caused further casualties

The "Blitz Spirit" — Myth and Reality

The traditional narrative of universal solidarity and cheerful endurance has been challenged by historians.

Traditional View	Revisionist View
Universal solidarity and class unity	Significant class tensions — looting, black marketeering, resentment of inequality
Stoic endurance	Widespread anxiety, depression, and psychiatric casualties
"We're all in it together"	The rich could afford better shelters, evacuate to country houses, and avoid the worst hardships
Democratic levelling	The war reinforced some inequalities while challenging others

Historiographical Debate: Angus Calder's The Myth of the Blitz (1991) challenged the heroic narrative, arguing that it was partly constructed by wartime propaganda and post-war nostalgia. However, Calder did not deny that genuine solidarity existed — rather, he argued that the reality was more complex than the myth. Juliet Gardiner's Wartime Britain (2004) provided a nuanced account that acknowledged both solidarity and tension. Mark Connelly's We Can Take It! (2004) analysed how the Blitz myth was constructed and sustained.

---

The Beveridge Report (December 1942)