The Elizabethan Religious Settlement

When Elizabeth I came to the throne on 17 November 1558, England's religious identity was deeply uncertain. In the space of just eleven years, the country had swung from the conservative Protestantism of Henry VIII's final years, to the radical Protestantism of Edward VI, to the restored Catholicism of Mary I. Elizabeth's response — the Religious Settlement of 1559 — was one of the most significant and enduring achievements of the Tudor period. It established a Church of England that was Protestant in doctrine but retained many Catholic elements in practice, creating a "middle way" (via media) that would define English religion for centuries.

---

The Settlement of 1559

The core of the Elizabethan Religious Settlement consisted of two Acts of Parliament and a set of Royal Injunctions.

Act of Supremacy 1559

Feature	Detail
Royal title	Elizabeth was declared Supreme Governor (not Supreme Head) of the Church of England — a deliberate change from Henry VIII's title to avoid offending those who believed a woman could not be head of the Church
Oath of Supremacy	All clergy, judges, and royal officials were required to swear an oath accepting the queen's supremacy; refusal meant loss of office
Penalties	First refusal: loss of office; second refusal: praemunire (forfeiture of property); third refusal: treason (death)
Repeal of heresy laws	The Marian heresy laws were repealed, ending the burning of heretics

Act of Uniformity 1559

Feature	Detail
Book of Common Prayer	A revised Prayer Book was imposed, based on the 1552 version but with crucial modifications to make it more acceptable to Catholics
Communion wording	Combined the words from the 1549 and 1552 Prayer Books, allowing both Catholic and Protestant interpretations of the Eucharist
Church attendance	Everyone was required to attend church on Sundays and holy days; absentees faced a fine of twelve pence per absence (recusancy fines)
Vestments	Clergy were required to wear traditional vestments — a concession to conservative opinion

Royal Injunctions 1559

Injunction	Detail
English Bible	Every church was to have a copy of the Bible in English
Preaching licence	Only licensed preachers could deliver sermons; others had to read from the Book of Homilies
Images and relics	"Superstitious" images were to be removed, but a crucifix and candles were permitted in the royal chapel (a concession that angered Puritans)
Clergy	Were to be resident in their parishes and of good moral character
Music	Hymns in English were encouraged; elaborate Latin polyphony was discouraged but not banned

Key Definition: Via media ("middle way") describes the Elizabethan Religious Settlement's attempt to find a compromise between Catholicism and Protestantism. The Settlement was Protestant in theology (rejecting papal authority and key Catholic doctrines) but retained Catholic-looking ceremonies and structures (bishops, vestments, church calendar).

Exam Tip: The Settlement was a masterpiece of constructive ambiguity. The communion wording, for example, allowed Catholics to believe they were receiving the body and blood of Christ, while Protestants could interpret it as a purely symbolic act. This deliberate vagueness was a political strength but also sowed the seeds of future conflict with both Puritans and Catholics who wanted greater clarity.

---

The Thirty-Nine Articles 1563

The doctrinal foundation of the Elizabethan Church was set out in the Thirty-Nine Articles, approved by Convocation in 1563 and given statutory authority in 1571.

Key Doctrine	Position
Scripture	The Bible is the ultimate authority in matters of faith (a Protestant position)
Justification	Salvation by faith alone (Protestant)
Sacraments	Only two sacraments recognised: baptism and the Lord's Supper (Protestant — Catholics recognise seven)
Eucharist	Rejected transubstantiation but affirmed a "real" spiritual presence — deliberately ambiguous
Predestination	Article 17 included a carefully worded statement on predestination, close to Calvinist theology but not explicitly so
Church authority	The Church has authority in matters of ceremony and rite, but not to require belief in anything not found in Scripture

---

The Catholic Threat

Despite the Settlement's attempt at comprehensiveness, it faced sustained challenge from Catholics who refused to accept Elizabeth's religious authority.

Seminary Priests and Jesuits