Question 4: Critical Evaluation

Question 4 is the highest-tariff question in Section A, worth 20 marks. It tests your ability to evaluate a text critically and support your evaluation with textual references. This is assessed under AO4 and requires you to engage with a given statement, deciding to what extent you agree or disagree with it.

---

What the Question Looks Like

A typical Q4 might read:

Focus this part of your answer on the second part of the source, from line 20 to the end. A student said: "The writer makes the reader feel great sympathy for the main character." To what extent do you agree?

The question always includes:

• A focus area (specific line references)
• A statement from a student or reader
• The prompt "To what extent do you agree?"

---

What the Examiner Wants