You are viewing a free preview of this lesson.
Subscribe to unlock all 10 lessons in this course and every other course on LearningBro.
Themes are the big ideas that run through the entire novel. AQA expects you to track these themes across the text and connect them to context. This lesson covers three closely linked themes: independence, gender, and morality.
Independence is the driving force of the novel — Jane's relentless pursuit of autonomy, self-respect, and the right to make her own choices.
| Stage of the novel | How independence is presented | Key quote |
|---|---|---|
| Gateshead (Chs 1–4) | Independence as rebellion — Jane's refusal to submit to injustice | "I resisted all the way: a new thing for me" (Ch. 2) |
| Lowood (Chs 5–10) | Independence as aspiration — Jane yearns for a wider life | "I desired liberty; for liberty I gasped; for liberty I uttered a prayer" (Ch. 10) |
| Thornfield (Chs 11–27) | Independence vs love — Jane must choose self-respect over passion | "I care for myself... I will respect myself" (Ch. 27) |
| Moor House (Chs 28–35) | Independence achieved — financial security and family | Jane shares her £20,000 inheritance equally with her cousins |
| Ferndean (Chs 36–38) | Independence in partnership — Jane freely chooses marriage as an equal | "Reader, I married him" (Ch. 38) |
Brontë does not present independence as selfishness or isolation. Rather:
Examiner's tip: When writing about independence, always connect it to context. Victorian women had almost no legal or financial independence. A married woman's property belonged to her husband. Brontë's insistence that Jane must be financially independent before she can marry Rochester is a radical statement about the conditions necessary for equality in marriage.
Gender is inseparable from independence in Jane Eyre. Brontë directly challenges the Victorian expectation that women should be passive, silent, and subordinate.
| "Angel in the House" ideal | Jane's reality |
|---|---|
| Selfless, devoted to husband | Self-respecting, refuses to lose herself in another |
| Physically beautiful | Repeatedly described as "plain" and "little" |
| Silent and obedient | Speaks out passionately against injustice |
| Dependent on male protection | Insists on earning her own way |
| Domestic and confined | Yearns for wider experience and liberty |
"Women are supposed to be very calm generally: but women feel just as men feel; they need exercise for their faculties, and a field for their efforts, as much as their brothers do; they suffer from too rigid a restraint, too absolute a stagnation, precisely as men would suffer" (Chapter 12)
This is one of the most explicitly proto-feminist passages in Victorian literature. Brontë directly addresses the reader, arguing that the difference between men and women is imposed by society, not nature.
"I am no bird; and no net ensnares me; I am a free human being with an independent will, which I now exert to leave you" (Chapter 23)
The bird imagery is significant: Victorian women were often compared to caged birds — decorative, confined, and unable to fly. Jane rejects this image entirely.
Brontë uses the male characters to explore different models of masculinity:
| Male character | Model of masculinity | Critique |
|---|---|---|
| John Reed | Bullying, entitled, violent | Represents toxic privilege |
| Mr Brocklehurst | Patriarchal, hypocritical authority | Uses religion to control women |
| Rochester | Passionate but possessive | Tries to "own" Jane; must be humbled |
| St John Rivers | Cold, controlling, repressive | Wants to use Jane as a tool |
Examiner's tip: A sophisticated response will discuss how Brontë critiques multiple forms of male power, not just one. Rochester's passionate dominance and St John's cold control are presented as equally dangerous to Jane's autonomy — she must reject both before she can find a relationship of genuine equality.
Morality in Jane Eyre is personal, internal, and deeply felt. Brontë rejects external moral authority (Brocklehurst's religious hypocrisy, St John's rigid duty) in favour of an individual moral conscience.
| Test | Chapter | Temptation | What Jane chooses | Why |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Rochester's plea | 27 | Stay with the man she loves as his mistress | Self-respect and moral principle | "I care for myself" — even love cannot justify moral compromise |
| St John's proposal | 34–35 | Marry a man she respects but does not love, for God's work | Emotional truth and personal identity | "If I join St John, I abandon half myself" |
JANE'S MORAL BALANCE
|
______________|_______________
| |
PASSION alone DUTY alone
(Rochester, Ch. 27) (St John, Ch. 34)
= loss of self-respect = loss of identity
= becoming a "slave of passion" = becoming a "slave of duty"
| |
|______________________________|
|
BOTH are rejected
|
Jane finds balance
at Ferndean (Ch. 38)
Brontë distinguishes between authentic morality (personal conscience, guided by both feeling and principle) and institutional religion (rules imposed by external authority):
| Form of religion | Character | Brontë's judgement |
|---|---|---|
| Hypocritical | Brocklehurst — starves children while his family is wealthy | Condemned |
| Passive / otherworldly | Helen Burns — accepts all suffering as God's will | Admired but insufficient |
| Cold / repressive | St John — suppresses all human emotion for duty | Critiqued |
| Personal / balanced | Jane — follows her conscience, which combines feeling and faith | Endorsed |
Examiner's tip: When writing about morality, emphasise that Jane's moral strength is internal, not externally imposed. She does not obey Brocklehurst's rules or St John's demands — she obeys her own conscience. This is a radical Victorian idea: Brontë suggests that individual moral judgement is more trustworthy than institutional authority.
Question: How does Brontë present the importance of independence in Jane Eyre?
Subscribe to continue reading
Get full access to this lesson and all 10 lessons in this course.