You are viewing a free preview of this lesson.
Subscribe to unlock all 10 lessons in this course and every other course on LearningBro.
The intellectual and moral heart of The History Boys lies in the contrast between its two central teachers: Hector and Irwin. Understanding their philosophies, their flaws, and their relationship to the boys is essential for any GCSE essay on the play.
Hector is an experienced, middle-aged English and General Studies teacher. He is large, physically imposing, eccentric, and deeply passionate about literature, music, and culture. He has taught at the school for many years and is beloved by the boys.
| Aspect | Detail |
|---|---|
| Full name | Hector (first name never given — symbolic distance) |
| Age | Middle-aged, approaching retirement |
| Subject | General Studies |
| Teaching style | Eclectic, performative, participatory |
| Core belief | Knowledge is its own reward — "passing it on" |
| Flaw | Inappropriately touches the boys on his motorbike |
| Fate | Dies in a motorbike accident at the end of the play |
Hector believes that education should be about the accumulation of knowledge, culture, and emotional wisdom — not about passing exams. His lessons involve:
"All knowledge is precious whether or not it serves the slightest human use." — Hector
For Hector, the purpose of learning is transformation of the soul, not advancement of the career. He wants the boys to carry poetry and music with them as a form of emotional armour — something that will comfort them in moments of loneliness, grief, or doubt.
"The best moments in reading are when you come across something — a thought, a feeling, a way of looking at things — that you'd thought special, particular to you. And here it is, set down by someone else, a person you've never met, maybe even someone long dead. And it is as if a hand has come out and taken yours." — Hector
Examiner's tip: This quotation is one of the most frequently cited in GCSE essays. When you use it, analyse the metaphor of the hand — it creates a physical, intimate connection between reader and writer, suggesting that literature transcends time and isolation. Note the irony that Hector's own "hand" — his physical touching of the boys — corrupts this ideal.
Hector's defining flaw is his sexual misconduct. He touches the boys on his motorbike — what the boys call "Hector's hand." This behaviour is:
| Perspective | How the misconduct is treated |
|---|---|
| The boys | Embarrassed tolerance — they take turns, joke about it |
| Mrs Lintott | Aware but protective of Hector — she understands his complexity |
| The Headmaster | Knew all along — acts only when his own position is threatened |
| Bennett (the author) | Presents it as morally complex — not excused but not the whole story |
Examiner's tip: A sophisticated response will acknowledge that Hector's behaviour is wrong while also recognising that the play deliberately complicates the audience's judgement. Bennett forces us to hold two truths simultaneously: Hector is a great teacher and a flawed man. The play's moral power comes from this refusal to simplify.
Hector has strong echoes of the tragic hero:
Irwin is a young, recently hired supply teacher brought in by the Headmaster to coach the boys for Oxbridge entrance. He is clever, insecure, and closeted. He represents a radically different approach to education.
| Aspect | Detail |
|---|---|
| First name | Tom (rarely used) |
| Age | Young — recently graduated |
| Subject | History / Exam technique |
| Teaching style | Provocative, contrarian, strategic |
| Core belief | History is interpretation — success lies in presentation |
| Flaw | Inauthenticity — he performs confidence he does not feel |
| Fate | Injured in the motorbike crash; becomes a TV spin doctor |
Irwin teaches the boys to think of history as performance:
"History nowadays is not a matter of conviction. It's a performance. It's entertainment. And if it isn't, make it so." — Irwin
| Strengths | Weaknesses |
|---|---|
| Intellectually sharp | Morally evasive — treats truth as optional |
| Gives the boys practical exam skills | His approach has no ethical foundation |
| Challenges them to think differently | He is insecure and performs a confidence he lacks |
| Understands how institutions work | He lies about his own background (claims Oxford, actually Bristol) |
Examiner's tip: Irwin's lie about attending Oxford is crucial. It reveals that his entire philosophy — treating truth as malleable, prioritising presentation over substance — extends to his own identity. He is living proof of his own argument: if you spin convincingly enough, people believe you.
Irwin is closeted. He is attracted to Dakin but is paralysed by fear and social convention. Unlike Hector — who acts on his desires covertly — Irwin cannot act at all.
The contrast is significant:
| Hector | Irwin |
|---|---|
| Acts on desire (touches the boys) | Cannot act on desire (paralysed) |
| Open in his emotions | Repressed and controlled |
| Physically large and present | Physically slight and uncertain |
| Driven by passion | Driven by fear |
In the epilogue, Irwin becomes a television historian and government spin doctor — someone who uses historical arguments to justify political decisions. This is Bennett's most damning judgement: Irwin's educational philosophy leads directly to political manipulation.
The conflict between Hector and Irwin is the play's structural spine. It represents a fundamental disagreement about the purpose of education:
| Question | Hector's answer | Irwin's answer |
|---|---|---|
| What is education for? | Personal enrichment and emotional depth | Professional success and strategic advantage |
| What is the value of knowledge? | Intrinsic — knowledge is its own reward | Instrumental — knowledge is a tool |
| How should you read a poem? | Feel it, memorise it, let it change you | Analyse it, use it as evidence in an argument |
| What is history? | A record of human experience | A narrative that can be shaped and spun |
| What is truth? | Something sacred and objective | Something constructed and negotiable |
Subscribe to continue reading
Get full access to this lesson and all 10 lessons in this course.