Externalities: Negative Externalities

A negative externality exists when the production or consumption of a good imposes costs on third parties who are not involved in the original transaction and who receive no compensation for those costs. These external costs mean that the market price of the good is too low and the quantity produced or consumed is too high relative to the social optimum. Arthur Cecil Pigou (1920), in The Economics of Welfare, was the first to propose that the divergence between private and social costs constitutes a fundamental market failure requiring corrective action.

Key Definition: A negative externality is a spillover cost imposed on third parties as a result of production or consumption, for which no compensation is paid. It causes the social cost to exceed the private cost.

---

Private Costs, External Costs, and Social Costs

To understand negative externalities, it is essential to distinguish three types of cost:

Cost Type	Definition	Example
Private cost	The cost borne directly by the producer or consumer involved in the transaction	A factory's costs of raw materials, wages, and rent
External cost	The cost imposed on third parties not involved in the transaction	Air pollution from the factory causing respiratory illness in local residents
Social cost	The total cost to society: private cost + external cost	The factory's production costs plus the health costs, environmental damage, and reduced property values

The fundamental relationship is:

Social Cost = Private Cost + External Cost

Or, in marginal terms:

Marginal Social Cost (MSC) = Marginal Private Cost (MPC) + Marginal External Cost (MEC)

---

Negative Externalities in Production

A negative externality in production occurs when the production process imposes costs on third parties.

Examples in the UK context:

• A chemical factory discharging waste into a river, killing fish and harming the livelihood of downstream fishermen
• A construction project creating noise pollution and congestion for local residents
• Carbon dioxide emissions from power stations contributing to climate change — the UK's Committee on Climate Change has estimated the social cost of carbon at over £70 per tonne
• Agricultural run-off of nitrates and pesticides contaminating water supplies, requiring expensive treatment by water companies

In these cases, the MPC to the firm is less than the MSC because the firm does not pay for the external costs it imposes. The market produces where MPC = MPB (the firm maximises private profit), but the socially optimal output is where MSC = MSB.

The Diagram

On a standard negative externality in production diagram:

• The MPC (or supply) curve lies below the MSC curve — the vertical distance between them represents the MEC (marginal external cost)
• The demand curve represents both MPB and MSB (assuming no externality in consumption)
• The market equilibrium is at Qm (where MPC = MPB), but the socially optimal output is at Q* (where MSC = MSB)
• Since Qm > Q*, the market over-produces relative to the social optimum
• The welfare loss triangle is the area between MSC and MSB (or MPB) from Q* to Qm — this represents the net cost to society of the excess production

Exam Tip: When drawing externality diagrams, always label all curves (MSC, MPC, MSB/MPB), mark both Qm and Q*, shade the welfare loss triangle, and annotate the vertical distance between MSC and MPC as the MEC. Clear diagrams are essential for full marks.

---

Negative Externalities in Consumption

A negative externality in consumption occurs when an individual's consumption of a good imposes costs on third parties.

Examples in the UK context:

• Smoking in public places — before the Smoking Ban of 2007, passive smoking imposed health costs on non-smokers in pubs, restaurants, and workplaces
• Alcohol consumption leading to anti-social behaviour, NHS treatment costs, and policing costs — Public Health England estimated that alcohol-related harm costs the NHS approximately £3.5 billion per year
• Playing loud music late at night, reducing the quality of sleep for neighbours
• Driving a car in a congested urban area, increasing journey times for all other road users — the London congestion charge, introduced in 2003 under Mayor Ken Livingstone, was designed to address this

In these cases, the MPB to the consumer exceeds the MSB to society. The individual consumer considers only their private benefit (the enjoyment of smoking, drinking, or driving) but not the costs imposed on others.

The Diagram

On a negative externality in consumption diagram:

• The MSB curve lies below the MPB (or demand) curve — the vertical distance is the MEC
• The supply curve represents both MPC and MSC (assuming no externality in production)
• The market equilibrium is at Qm (where MPC = MPB), but Q* is where MSC = MSB
• Again, Qm > Q* — the good is over-consumed
• The welfare loss triangle is between MPB and MSB from Q* to Qm