You are viewing a free preview of this lesson.
Subscribe to unlock all 14 lessons in this course and every other course on LearningBro.
Spec mapping: AQA 7138 Unit 3.1.2 — Forms of business and stakeholders (refer to the official AQA specification document for exact wording). This lesson develops the incorporated company form at the depth a Paper 1 / Paper 2 synoptic question expects — the legal architecture of the separate legal entity, limited-liability protection, the design and rights of ordinary and preference shares, the calculation and interpretation of market capitalisation (Annex 7 formula 1), the dividend and share-price mechanisms by which shareholders earn returns, the contrast between private (Ltd) and public (plc) limited companies, the AIM/main-market choice, and the structural implications for stakeholder accountability under shareholder primacy vs the stakeholder approach. Top-band 9-mark Assess answers visibly deploy Annex 8 sophisticated concepts.
Connects to:
Definition: A limited company is a business that has its own legal identity, separate from its shareholders. The company can own assets, enter contracts, sue and be sued in its own name. Shareholders' liability for the company's debts is limited to the capital they have committed.
The act of creating a limited company is called incorporation — the legal process of registering the business with Companies House (in England and Wales; Companies House Scotland and Companies House Northern Ireland for the devolved jurisdictions). Once incorporated, the business becomes a separate legal entity — a legal "person" in its own right.
To incorporate a UK limited company, the founders must file:
Once Companies House registers the company, it issues a certificate of incorporation — the legal birth certificate. From that moment the company exists as a separate legal entity capable of owning property, entering contracts, employing staff and incurring debts independently of its shareholders.
Definition: Limited liability means a shareholder's financial responsibility for the company's debts is capped at the amount they have invested (or committed to invest) in shares. Personal assets — home, savings, other investments — are protected from creditor claims on the company.
Limited liability is the single most consequential feature of the company form. It is the structural reason most growing businesses incorporate, because it converts an open-ended personal-asset exposure (the unlimited-liability bridge of the sole-trader / partnership form) into a bounded, calculable risk (capped at the equity stake).
| Dimension | Unincorporated (sole trader / partnership) | Incorporated (Ltd / plc) |
|---|---|---|
| Legal status | Owner and business are the same legal person | Company is a separate legal entity |
| Liability | Unlimited; personal assets at risk | Limited to capital committed |
| Continuity | Tied to the owner(s) | Indefinite — survives shareholder turnover |
| Capital-raising | Personal savings, retained profit, debt | Adds the equity-share channel (private placement or public market) |
| Disclosure | Minimal | Annual accounts filed at Companies House (plus additional plc obligations) |
| Tax regime | Income tax + National Insurance on profits | Corporation tax on profits; dividends taxed in shareholders' hands |
| Operational cost | Trivial | Higher — formal accounts, statutory audits (above thresholds), corporate-governance obligations |
The limited-liability advantage is real but is not free. Incorporation carries set-up cost, ongoing compliance cost, public-disclosure obligations and a more complex tax position. The choice between forms is a trade-off, not a no-brainer.
The risk vs uncertainty distinction (Annex 8 analytical concept #10) is the analytical lens here: incorporation converts the open-ended uncertainty of unlimited-liability exposure into bounded, knowable risk capped at the equity stake. This is one of the structural reasons institutional investors and venture-capital firms will not invest in unincorporated businesses — the unbounded liability is incompatible with their portfolio-risk frameworks.
Definition: A private limited company (Ltd) is a company whose shares are held privately and cannot be offered for sale to the general public. Share transfers typically require board or shareholder approval.
The Ltd form is the default UK incorporated form for small and medium-sized businesses. There are several million UK Ltd companies; the majority of British businesses with any meaningful scale operate as Ltds rather than as plcs.
| Feature | Detail |
|---|---|
| Ownership | Shares held by a typically small group — founders, families, employees, private investors |
| Share transfer | Cannot be offered to the public; transfers usually need board / shareholder approval per the Articles |
| Minimum shareholders | 1 (the same person can be sole shareholder and sole director) |
| Minimum directors | 1 |
| Minimum share capital | No statutory minimum |
| Financial reporting | Annual accounts filed at Companies House; small-company exemptions reduce disclosure for businesses below specified turnover and balance-sheet thresholds |
| Name | Ends in "Ltd" or "Limited" |
A material number of large UK businesses choose to remain Ltds even when their scale would qualify them to list. Examples include certain large family-owned engineering, manufacturing and retail groups that retain Ltd status to preserve long-horizon decision-making and avoid the short-term-return pressure of public-market accountability. Specific company examples (figures fabricated for illustrative purposes where stated) include a large UK construction-equipment manufacturer that has remained family-owned across multiple generations, a major British technology-and-engineering firm whose founder has explicitly chosen Ltd status to preserve operational autonomy, and the employee-owned John Lewis Partnership which operates under a partnership-trust structure distinct from the listed-plc model.
The strategic case for remaining a Ltd typically rests on:
The corresponding limitations are restricted capital-raising (no public-market access), restricted exit options (founders cannot easily liquidate stakes), and reduced public profile compared with listed peers.
Definition: A public limited company (plc) is a company whose shares are eligible to be offered to the public, typically through a listing on a recognised stock exchange (in the UK, the Main Market or AIM of the London Stock Exchange).
| Feature | Detail |
|---|---|
| Ownership | Shares freely tradable on a stock exchange; ownership typically distributed across many institutional and retail investors |
| Minimum allotted share capital | £50,000, of which at least 25 % must be paid up |
| Minimum shareholders | 1 (statutorily; in practice, thousands or millions for listed plcs) |
| Minimum directors | 2 |
| Company secretary | Required and must be suitably qualified |
| Financial reporting | Full annual report and accounts; subject to listing-rule disclosure (continuing obligations, market announcements); typically subject to statutory audit |
| Name | Ends in "plc" |
The London Stock Exchange operates two principal venues:
| Venue | Profile | Typical use case |
|---|---|---|
| Main Market (Premium / Standard segments) | Larger, more established companies; stricter listing rules and ongoing disclosure | Mature UK and international plcs; constituent of the FTSE indices |
| AIM (Alternative Investment Market) | Smaller, growth-stage companies; lighter regulatory regime | UK growth-stage plcs raising £5m–£100m; common for natural-resources, biotech and tech-growth firms |
AIM is a critical venue for the Paper 2 / Paper 3 case-study questions on growth-stage scaling. It offers genuine plc status (limited liability, public-market visibility, share liquidity, equity capital access) at lower listing cost and lighter ongoing disclosure than the Main Market. The trade-off is that AIM shares are typically more volatile and less liquid than Main Market shares.
Definition: Ordinary shares (sometimes called common shares or equity shares) carry voting rights at general meetings and a residual claim on profits and on assets in a winding-up. Preference shares carry a fixed dividend that ranks ahead of ordinary dividends but typically do not carry voting rights and have no participation in upside above the fixed dividend.
| Feature | Ordinary shares | Preference shares |
|---|---|---|
| Voting | Typically one vote per share | Typically no vote (some classes have limited voting rights) |
| Dividend | Discretionary; declared by directors out of distributable reserves | Fixed rate (e.g. 5 % of nominal value); ranks ahead of ordinary dividend |
| Upside participation | Full — residual claim on profits and capital | Capped — typically receives only the fixed dividend |
| Risk profile | Higher — last to be paid in distress | Lower — paid ahead of ordinary; can be cumulative (missed dividends accumulate) |
| Use case | Founders, equity investors, institutional shareholders | Yield-seeking investors; hybrid debt-equity instruments |
The exam-relevant point is that the equity-share channel is structurally different from the debt channel — equity investors share in the upside but bear the downside risk; debt investors have a fixed claim that ranks ahead of equity but have no participation in upside. The mix between the two (the gearing — Annex 8 financial concept #15) is one of the core financing-structure decisions a company makes.
Annex 7 formula 1:
Market capitalisation = Number of issued shares × Current share price
Market capitalisation (market cap) is the stock-market valuation of the entire company. It fluctuates continuously as the share price moves with new information about the company's prospects, the sector and the macro environment.
A hypothetical UK plc has 240 million ordinary shares in issue. The current share price is £8.40.
Market cap = 240,000,000 × £8.40 = £2.016 billion
If the share price rises to £9.20 on positive trading-update news:
New market cap = 240,000,000 × £9.20 = £2.208 billion
The £192 million increase in market cap is the market's revised valuation of the future cash flows the company is expected to deliver — not an increase in the company's reported assets, which are unchanged.
| Band | Approximate market cap | Typical examples |
|---|---|---|
| Mega-cap | Over £100 billion | Largest global technology, energy and pharmaceutical companies |
| Large-cap | £10–100 billion | FTSE 100 constituents in retail, banking, energy, consumer goods |
| Mid-cap | £1–10 billion | FTSE 250 constituents — branded retail, food service, niche industrials |
| Small-cap | Under £1 billion | Many AIM-listed companies; specialised industrial and growth-stage businesses |
Market share (Annex 8 financial concept #14) is a related but distinct concept: Market share (%) = (Firm's revenue ÷ Total market revenue) × 100. Market capitalisation reflects what investors will pay for the company's equity; market share reflects the company's commercial footprint in its addressable market. The two are correlated (higher market share often supports higher market cap) but not identical — a company with low market share can have a high market cap if investors believe it will scale rapidly.
Definition: A dividend is a payment a company makes to its shareholders out of distributable profits, typically declared by the board and approved by shareholders at the AGM. Dividend yield expresses the annual dividend as a percentage of the share price.
Dividend yield (%) = (Annual dividend per share ÷ Current share price) × 100
Dividends and dividend yield are Annex 8 sophisticated concepts (financial concept #13). A Top-band 9-mark Assess answer on a listing or financing decision visibly deploys dividend-yield reasoning where relevant.
A hypothetical UK plc pays an annual dividend of 32p per share. The current share price is £8.40.
Dividend yield = (£0.32 ÷ £8.40) × 100 = 3.81 %
Dividend yield is one of the principal metrics by which investors compare the income-generating attractiveness of different shares. Mature, cash-generative businesses (utilities, mature consumer-goods, established banks) typically offer dividend yields in the 3–6 % range; growth-stage companies often pay no dividend at all, preferring to reinvest cash in scaling.
Gearing (%) = (Non-current liabilities ÷ Total equity + Non-current liabilities) × 100
Gearing (Annex 8 financial concept #15) measures the proportion of long-term financing that comes from debt rather than equity. High-geared companies have higher fixed financing costs (interest payments) and are more vulnerable to interest-rate rises or revenue downturns; low-geared companies have more financial flexibility but may underuse the tax-deductibility of debt interest. The financing-structure decision is therefore a trade-off between financial flexibility and capital-cost efficiency.
| Feature | Ltd | plc |
|---|---|---|
| Share offer | Private only | Can offer to the public |
| Minimum share capital | None | £50,000 allotted (25 % paid up) |
| Minimum directors | 1 | 2 |
| Company secretary | Optional | Required and qualified |
| Disclosure regime | Companies House annual accounts; small-company exemptions | Full annual report + listing-rule continuing obligations |
| Capital-raising | Private placement; debt | Public equity issue (IPO, secondary issue); debt; private placement |
| Control | Concentrated; easy to retain | Can be widely dispersed; vulnerable to hostile takeover |
| Stakeholder pressure | Lower; shareholders typically known and aligned | Higher; institutional investors and analysts push short-run return |
| Set-up and ongoing cost | Lower | Higher (listing fees, advisory costs, compliance) |
| Exit options for founders | Limited (private buyer, secondary sale) | Liquid market for shares; founder stake can be sold publicly |
flowchart TD
PrivateLtd["Private Ltd<br/>(growth-stage,<br/>capital-constrained)"] --> Question{"Capital needs<br/>exceed private channels?"}
Question -->|"no"| StayLtd["Stay Ltd<br/>(private placement,<br/>debt, retained profit)"]
Question -->|"yes"| Choose{"Which venue?"}
Choose -->|"smaller raise,<br/>growth-stage,<br/>lighter regulation"| AIM["AIM listing<br/>(£5m-£100m typical)"]
Choose -->|"larger raise,<br/>established business,<br/>FTSE eligibility"| Main["Main Market<br/>listing"]
AIM --> Trade-offs["Trade-offs:<br/>capital access<br/>+ public profile<br/>+ share liquidity<br/>vs scrutiny<br/>+ disclosure<br/>+ short-termism risk<br/>+ takeover exposure"]
Main --> Trade-offs
Trade-offs --> Decision{"Strategic decision"}
Decision -->|"accept"| FloatNow["Proceed with IPO"]
Decision -->|"reject"| StayLtd
Decision -->|"defer"| PrivateLtd
style PrivateLtd fill:#1d4ed8,color:#fff
style FloatNow fill:#15803d,color:#fff
style Trade-offs fill:#a16207,color:#fff
The flotation decision is, structurally, a strategic trade-off — access to capital and exit liquidity on one side, against disclosure, scrutiny and short-termism pressure on the other. The diagram surfaces the AIM-vs-Main-Market choice that growth-stage UK companies face; AIM is materially the more common venue for SMEs scaling through £5m–£100m raises, while the Main Market is typically reserved for mature businesses raising larger sums.
| Advantages | Disadvantages |
|---|---|
| Access to large equity capital pools | Listing fees and ongoing advisory costs can run into millions |
| Increased public profile and credibility | Continuous disclosure (RNS announcements, half-year results, annual report) |
| Liquidity for founder and early-investor stakes | Quarterly-earnings pressure can distort long-run strategic choices |
| Share-based compensation more attractive to recruit talent | Hostile-takeover exposure once shares are widely dispersed |
| External validation of valuation through market price | Founder-control dilution as new investors enter |
Recent UK listings have illustrated the risks. Several high-profile IPOs (in retail, food delivery and fintech) have experienced sharp first-day price falls when the issue price exceeded what the broader market was willing to pay, signalling either over-optimistic pricing by advisers or genuine post-listing rethink by investors. The exam-relevant lesson is that flotation is not a destination — it is a financing-and-governance choice with material ongoing consequences.
Subscribe to continue reading
Get full access to this lesson and all 14 lessons in this course.