You are viewing a free preview of this lesson.
Subscribe to unlock all 10 lessons in this course and every other course on LearningBro.
Setting in prose fiction is never merely a backdrop — it is a structural element that shapes meaning. The places where love unfolds, the landscapes that surround it, and the atmospheres that contain it are central to how novelists represent emotional experience. In all three anchor texts, geography is moral and psychological: the storm-battered moor is Heathcliff and Catherine's love; the lush Froom valley is Tess and Angel's doomed idyll; the bay between West Egg and East Egg is the class gulf between Gatsby and Daisy. For Paper 1 Section C you need to analyse how setting creates, reflects, and complicates the theme of love — and how a novelist's extended, accreting use of place compares with the compressed landscape imagery of a love poem.
Spec Mapping — Paper 1, Section C: prose (Love Through the Ages comparison). The dominant AO is AO2 (analysis of how setting, atmosphere and symbolic landscape shape meaning), supported by AO1 (terminology: pathetic fallacy, the gothic, the pastoral, symbolic setting, liminal space). AO3 is strong here — the gothic and the pastoral are period-bound literary inheritances, and Hardy's countryside is shadowed by Victorian agrarian and sexual realities. AO4 connects the novel's symbolic places to nature and landscape imagery in love poetry; AO5 brings in feminist and Marxist readings of the gothic house and the moor.
The pathetic fallacy — attributing human emotion to the natural world — is the most familiar technique for linking place to feeling, but the strongest novelists go further than matching weather to mood: they make setting embody the psychological and social conditions of love. The aim in analysis is always to move from identification ("set on the moors") to argument ("the moor is the externalised form of a love that recognises no social boundary").
The gothic tradition — wild landscapes, exposed houses, storms, the supernatural, the threat of confinement — supplies a vocabulary for love that is dangerous, transgressive and psychologically extreme. Wuthering Heights is the supreme example of setting as meaning, and the structuring contrast between the two houses organises the whole novel. Lockwood's opening gloss is programmatic:
"Wuthering Heights is the name of Mr Heathcliff's dwelling. 'Wuthering' being a significant provincial adjective, descriptive of the atmospheric tumult to which its station is exposed in stormy weather." (Wuthering Heights, Ch. 1)
"Atmospheric tumult" is the weather of the love at the novel's centre. The Heights — exposed, storm-beaten, socially excluded — is set against Thrushcross Grange, with its civilisation, refinement and respectability. Catherine's tragedy is spatial: she belongs to both worlds but can inhabit only one, and her choice of the Grange (Edgar) over the Heights (Heathcliff) is a choice of social position over elemental truth. Her own imagery maps directly onto the two houses:
"Whatever our souls are made of, his and mine are the same; and Linton's is as different as a moonbeam from lightning, or frost from fire." (Wuthering Heights, Ch. 9)
Moonbeam/lightning and frost/fire are the cool cultivated Grange against the wild elemental Heights. Brontë makes the antithesis cosmic when Catherine declares the permanence of her bond to Heathcliff against the impermanence of everything else:
"If all else perished, and he remained, I should still continue to be; and if all else remained, and he were annihilated, the universe would turn to a mighty stranger: I should not seem a part of it." (Wuthering Heights, Ch. 9)
Here the whole world becomes setting: a universe without Heathcliff is an alien landscape ("a mighty stranger"). Place and passion are indistinguishable.
AO5 — Critical Interpretations: Sandra Gilbert and Susan Gubar, in The Madwoman in the Attic (1979), read the gothic spaces of nineteenth-century women's fiction as figures for female confinement and rage — the locked room, the wild beyond, the threshold. Applied to Wuthering Heights, the moor becomes the space of an unsocialised female desire that domestic respectability (the Grange) cannot contain. Terry Eagleton, by contrast, in Myths of Power (1975), reads the two houses as the terrain of a class struggle — the Heights as yeoman, the Grange as gentry — so that Catherine's choice of setting is a choice of social formation. The same landscape sustains a feminist and a Marxist reading; a top-band answer might hold both in tension.
The pastoral tradition idealises rural life as innocent and natural, and Tess gives us one of the most fully realised pastoral settings in English fiction — the Froom (Talbothays) valley, where Tess and Angel's courtship unfolds in fertile abundance:
"The season developed and matured. Another year's instalment of flowers, leaves, nightingales, thrushes, finches, and such ephemeral creatures, took up their positions where only a year ago others had stood in their place when these were nothing more than germs and inorganic particles." (Tess, Phase the Third, Ch. 20)
The diction of natural renewal ("developed and matured," "took up their positions") runs parallel to Tess's emotional and sexual awakening. But the single word "ephemeral" shadows the whole passage: the beauty is transient, and so is the happiness it figures. Crucially, Hardy subverts the pastoral he invokes. The countryside of Tess is not only Edenic; it is also a place of gruelling agricultural labour (the threshing machine at Flintcomb-Ash, "a red tyrant"), of economic precarity and of sexual violence — the assault at The Chase occurs in woodland that should, by pastoral convention, be benign. The novel's framing setting at the close — the pagan temple of Stonehenge, where Tess is taken sleeping before her arrest — recasts her destruction as ancient ritual sacrifice, timeless yet socially engineered.
AO3 — Context: By 1891 the pastoral was a long-established literary inheritance, and Hardy's readers knew its conventions of rural innocence. Hardy mobilises that expectation in order to break it: his Wessex is real agrarian England, where enclosure, mechanisation and the precariousness of the female farm labourer's position make the "idyll" untenable. The pastoral promise of natural love is destroyed by social reality, and that destruction is the argument of the book.
The Great Gatsby turns the geography of Long Island and New York into a moral map. Nick's account places the lovers on opposite shores:
"I lived at West Egg, the — well, the less fashionable of the two, though this is a most superficial tag to express the bizarre and not a little sinister contrast between them." (The Great Gatsby, Ch. 1)
The bay between West Egg (new money, Gatsby) and East Egg (old money, Daisy) is the physical form of a class barrier money cannot cross; the green light at the end of Daisy's dock is desire rendered as distance — visible, longed-for, unreachable. Between the Eggs and the city lies the novel's anti-pastoral:
"This is a valley of ashes — a fantastic farm where ashes grow like wheat into ridges and hills and grotesque gardens." (The Great Gatsby, Ch. 2)
The grotesque agricultural metaphor ("ashes grow like wheat") is a bitter inversion of pastoral fertility: this is the waste land on which the lovers' glittering world is built, presided over by the blank, godless eyes of Doctor T. J. Eckleburg. Setting here exposes the human and moral cost of the wealth that makes Gatsby's pursuit of Daisy possible.
A subtler dimension of setting is the threshold — the window, the door, the boundary between inside and out — which in love stories repeatedly marks the line between belonging and exclusion, the permitted and the forbidden. The most famous threshold in the anchor texts is the window of Catherine's old bedchamber, where Lockwood dreams the child-ghost begging to cross back in:
"'Let me in — let me in!'... 'I'm come home: I'd lost my way on the moor!'" (Wuthering Heights, Ch. 3)
The window is the perfect spatial emblem of Catherine's predicament: she is forever outside, locked out of the Heights and of Heathcliff by the choice she made for the Grange, longing across a boundary for a "home" she has forfeited. Setting here is not landscape but threshold — the love is figured as a soul pressed against a pane it cannot pass. The same liminal logic governs the green light at the end of Daisy's dock in Gatsby, a boundary-marker across water that Gatsby can see but never reach; and Stonehenge in Tess, where Tess crosses, asleep, the threshold between freedom and capture. Reading setting as threshold — attending to where characters are admitted, excluded, or suspended on a boundary — is a sophisticated AO2 move that lifts analysis above scenery.
Hardy's subversion of the pastoral reaches its bleakest in the threshing scene at Flintcomb-Ash, where industrial machinery violates the supposed idyll of the countryside. The threshing engine is rendered as a monstrous overlord:
"the red tyrant that the women had come to serve" (Tess, Phase the Sixth, Ch. 47)
The colour "red" (heat, blood, hellish energy) and the political noun "tyrant" recast rural labour as servitude under a mechanical despot — the opposite of pastoral ease. Crucially, this anti-pastoral setting is the antithesis of the fertile Talbothays valley where Tess and Angel's love bloomed: Hardy structures the novel so that the lovers' pastoral idyll in Phase the Third is answered, after the marriage's collapse, by this infernal landscape of toil in Phase the Sixth. Setting tracks the arc of love: the green valley of courtship gives way to the red machine of abandonment. Fitzgerald performs a comparable anti-pastoral inversion with his valley of ashes, where "ashes grow like wheat" — both novelists use a blighted agricultural image to expose the social and economic cruelty beneath a world that markets itself as natural or golden.
Atmosphere is built from sensory specifics — temperature, light, sound, texture — and from season. Brontë's storms, Hardy's seasonal cycle, Fitzgerald's stifling heat in the Plaza confrontation (Ch. 7), where the love plot reaches crisis as the day reaches its hottest: in each case the physical conditions externalise emotional states. The analytical task is to show that atmosphere is purposive — that the heat of the Plaza is not décor but pressure, forcing the latent conflict between Gatsby, Tom and Daisy into the open.
The Plaza chapter is worth dwelling on, because Fitzgerald makes climate the very medium of the love-crisis. The afternoon is "broiling," and the heat is not merely uncomfortable but unbearable, a pressure that strips away the social decorum within which the four characters have hitherto contained their rivalry. When Gatsby finally forces the confrontation — demanding that Daisy renounce her marriage — it is the heat that has loosened every tongue, so that what could not be said at a cool dinner table erupts in a sweltering hotel suite. Fitzgerald's choice of weather as catalyst is a sophisticated structural decision: the latent emotional conflict requires a physical correlative intense enough to detonate it, and the broiling day supplies that correlative. The reader feels the love-rivalry as bodily discomfort, so that atmosphere and emotion become indistinguishable. This is the opposite of décor; it is the engineering of crisis through environment. Crucially, the heat-soaked city scene is also anti-pastoral in its placement — the lovers' reckoning happens not in any green or natural space but in a man-made furnace, the modern metropolis at its most oppressive, which contrasts sharply with the cool elemental moor of Brontë or the fertile valley of Hardy and underscores that Gatsby's love belongs to a world of artifice and money rather than nature.
Brontë's atmospheric method is the inverse: where Fitzgerald confines his crisis to an airless interior, Brontë's weather is elemental and exterior, and it is woven into the very name of the house. Lockwood's gloss on "wuthering" as "descriptive of the atmospheric tumult to which its station is exposed in stormy weather" (Ch. 1) means that atmosphere is not an occasional effect in the novel but a permanent condition — the Heights is weather, perpetually exposed to the storm that the Grange, sheltered in its park, never feels. When Heathcliff overhears Catherine's "degrade" speech and flees, he disappears precisely into a storm; the night of his departure is one of violent thunder, the elements answering the rupture of the love. Brontë's atmospheric writing thus operates by pathetic fallacy raised to cosmic scale: the storm is not a mirror of one character's mood but a manifestation of the elemental forces the love itself embodies. The analytical point, once again, is purpose — Brontë makes weather the externalised form of a passion that recognises no shelter, no domesticity, no containment, so that to live at the Heights is to live permanently inside the storm of feeling.
Hardy's atmospheric resource is seasonal rather than meteorological, and it works by a slow accretion that neither Brontë's sudden storms nor Fitzgerald's single broiling day can match. The courtship at Talbothays is bathed in the warmth and abundance of high summer; the "season developed and matured" alongside the lovers, so that the very air seems thick with fertility and promise. But Hardy structures the seasonal atmosphere as an arc of decline: the summer of courtship gives way to the bleak, frost-bound winter of Flintcomb-Ash, where the atmosphere is one of grey deprivation, the women toiling in a "starve-acre" landscape under a pitiless sky. The seasonal cycle that should, in pastoral convention, turn endlessly back to spring becomes, for Tess, a one-way descent from warmth into cold, from abundance into want. Atmosphere in Hardy is therefore temporal — it charts the passage of love through time toward extinction, and the reader registers the cooling of the seasons as the cooling of Tess's fortunes. To compare the three novelists' atmospheric methods is to see three distinct technologies of feeling: Fitzgerald's confined heat as detonator, Brontë's elemental storm as permanent condition, Hardy's seasonal decline as the slow clock of tragedy.
Subscribe to continue reading
Get full access to this lesson and all 10 lessons in this course.