You are viewing a free preview of this lesson.
Subscribe to unlock all 10 lessons in this course and every other course on LearningBro.
Spec mapping (AQA 7037): Paper 2 (Human), §3.2.2 Changing Places — how places are represented in a variety of informal and formal ways (e.g. art, literature, film, music, photography, graffiti vs official statistics, census, maps, geospatial data); how agencies (governments, corporate bodies, community groups) seek to influence and present places; the re-imaging and rebranding of places. Synoptic links run to insider/outsider perspectives (Lesson 7 — who has power to represent) and to regeneration (Lesson 5 — re-imaging is a regeneration strategy). The lesson is weighted AO1 (types of representation and named theory — Urry's tourist gaze) and AO2 (critically analysing how and why places are represented), with a worked AO3 exercise contrasting formal data with informal representation.
Most of what we "know" about places we have never visited comes not from experience but from representation — art, literature, film, news, music, advertising, social media, and the apparently neutral formal representations of maps, census data and statistics. The crucial A-Level insight, following directly from Lesson 7, is that all representations are selective and positioned: they choose what to include and exclude, they serve particular purposes and audiences, and they are produced by agents with particular power and interests. The signature skill is therefore critical deconstruction — asking of any representation: who made this, for whom, what does it include and exclude, and with what effect on how the place is perceived and treated? The single most important distinction the specification draws is between formal representations (official, "objective" — census, maps, statistics, planning documents) and informal representations (subjective, creative — art, film, music, graffiti, social media); a strong answer shows that the "formal/objective" is also a construction, just one that hides its selectivity behind a claim to neutrality.
| Formal representations | Informal representations | |
|---|---|---|
| Examples | Census data, OS maps, IMD statistics, planning documents, official place-branding | Art, literature, film, TV, music, photography, graffiti, social media, blogs |
| Claim | Objective, authoritative, "factual" | Subjective, expressive, interpretive |
| Producers | Governments, agencies, corporations (institutional power) | Artists, residents, communities, individuals (often less powerful) |
| Strengths | Comparable, systematic, wide coverage, trusted | Capture meaning, emotion, lived experience, diverse voices |
| Limitations | Hide their selectivity; miss meaning/feeling; can stigmatise ("deprived") | Partial, hard to verify, not systematically comparable |
The key critical move is to puncture the formal/objective claim. A census category (which ethnicities are listed, how "household" is defined), a map's choices (what is shown, what omitted, the projection used), and an IMD label ("most deprived") are all the product of human decisions about what to measure and how — decisions that reflect the priorities and assumptions of those in power (Lesson 9). When a government statistic labels a neighbourhood "deprived", that is a representation with real effects (stigma, or investment), not a neutral fact. Recognising that formal and informal representations are both constructions — differing in their claim to authority, not in their fundamental selectivity — is the heart of sophisticated analysis here.
Artists have long shaped how places are perceived and valued. Artistic representations are never neutral — they select, emphasise, and interpret.
A-Level Analysis: When analysing artistic representations, consider: What has the artist chosen to include and exclude? What mood or atmosphere is created? How does this representation compare with the lived reality of the place? Whose perspective does it reflect?
A vivid demonstration of art's lasting power over place is the way Constable's pastoral Stour Valley became permanently marketed as "Constable Country" and Lowry's industrial scenes fixed the popular image of the working-class North — representations created generations ago that still shape how these places are perceived, visited and valued today. This is the geographer's key point: a representation can outlive and override the reality it depicts, so that the image of a place becomes a force in its own right, drawing tourists, conferring identity and even guiding planning and conservation. Graffiti and street art make the same point from the opposite direction: from contested "vandalism" to the way Banksy's works can transform the perceived value and identity of a wall, a building or a whole district (and even trigger their own micro-gentrification), street art shows representation being fought over on the very surface of the place itself — a literal contest over who gets to inscribe meaning on urban space.
Literature creates powerful and enduring place images that shape cultural understanding.
| Author | Work | Place | Representation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Thomas Hardy | Wessex novels | Dorset/Wiltshire | Rural England as timeless, tragic, shaped by landscape and fate |
| Charles Dickens | Oliver Twist, Bleak House | London | Victorian London as dark, polluted, socially divided |
| George Orwell | The Road to Wigan Pier | Northern England | Industrial poverty; working-class resilience |
| Alan Sillitoe | Saturday Night and Sunday Morning | Nottingham | Working-class urban life; factory culture; rebellion |
| Andrea Levy | Small Island | London | Post-war London through the eyes of Jamaican immigrants |
| Hanif Kureishi | The Buddha of Suburbia | South London | Suburban identity; multiculturalism; class aspiration |
Geographers study how literature shapes place perception:
Film and television are among the most influential media for shaping place perceptions.
The Full Monty (1997) — Represented post-industrial Sheffield as a place of unemployment, deindustrialisation, and social decline, but also of humour, resilience, and community solidarity. The film shaped external perceptions of Sheffield and northern England more broadly.
Trainspotting (1996) — Presented Edinburgh not as a festival city of Georgian elegance but as a place of heroin addiction, poverty, and social exclusion in housing schemes like Muirhouse and Leith. The film's opening monologue ("Choose life...") became iconic.
Downton Abbey (2010-2015) — Filmed at Highclere Castle, Hampshire, the series represented the English country house as a place of elegance, tradition, and social hierarchy. It boosted heritage tourism significantly — visitor numbers to Highclere doubled.
This Is England (2006) — Shane Meadows' film represented the Midlands in the early 1980s: council estates, National Front activity, skinhead culture, unemployment, and the impact of Thatcherism on working-class communities.
Film and television representations drive significant tourism:
News media representations powerfully shape place perceptions, often in problematic ways:
Media frames determine which aspects of a place are emphasised:
The concept of media framing deserves careful treatment because it is the mechanism by which representation acquires power over a place. A frame is not a lie — the crime a deficit frame reports may be real — but a selection and emphasis that makes some features salient and renders others invisible. Repeated deficit framing produces territorial stigmatisation (a concept associated with the sociologist Loïc Wacquant): a place acquires a "spoiled" reputation that then has material consequences entirely independent of conditions on the ground — employers discriminate against applicants with that postcode, insurers raise premiums, investors stay away, and residents internalise the stigma. The stigma can persist for decades after the conditions that produced it have changed, because the representation has become detached from the reality. This is why challenging deficit framing — through asset-based representation, community media and resident voice — is not mere image management but a substantive intervention in a place's prospects. It is also a direct application of Lesson 7's "power to define": those who control the dominant frame (national media, government) shape a place's fate over the heads of those who live there.
Music creates powerful place associations and expressions of place identity.
| Artist/Genre | Place | Representation |
|---|---|---|
| The Beatles | Liverpool | Creative, youthful, working-class innovation; "Penny Lane," "Strawberry Fields" |
| Arctic Monkeys | Sheffield | Post-industrial northern youth culture; nightlife; everyday observations |
| Grime (Dizzee Rascal, Stormzy) | East London | Urban energy; council estates; aspiration amid deprivation |
| Folk music | Rural Britain | Pastoral landscape; tradition; community; seasonal rhythms |
| Welsh male voice choirs | South Wales | Mining heritage; community solidarity; cultural identity |
| Oasis | Manchester | Working-class pride; swagger; Britpop northern identity |
Music can both reinforce and challenge place stereotypes. Grime, for example, gives voice to urban communities that are often negatively represented in mainstream media, creating alternative narratives of creativity, ambition, and belonging.
Social media has transformed how places are represented and experienced, and it is the representation form the specification most wants you to engage with as contemporary and contested. Its defining feature is a democratisation of representation: where once a small number of powerful agencies (broadcasters, newspapers, the state, the art establishment) controlled how places were depicted, now anyone with a smartphone can produce and circulate place-images to a global audience. This genuinely shifts power — communities can resist the deficit framing imposed on them, narrate their own places, and organise around place-based hashtags. But the democratisation is uneven and double-edged, as the subsections below show, and it introduces new gatekeepers (the platforms and their algorithms) in place of the old ones.
A-Level Analysis: Social media has democratised place representation — anyone with a smartphone can contribute to how a place is perceived. However, digital divides (age, income, digital literacy) mean that some voices remain louder than others. Social media representations also tend to be highly selective — people share the spectacular, the photogenic, and the extreme, not the mundane reality of daily life.
John Urry developed the concept of the tourist gaze to describe how tourism shapes the way places are seen, represented, and consumed.
Subscribe to continue reading
Get full access to this lesson and all 10 lessons in this course.