You are viewing a free preview of this lesson.
Subscribe to unlock all 10 lessons in this course and every other course on LearningBro.
The eleven years between Henry VIII's death on 28 January 1547 and Elizabeth I's accession on 17 November 1558 were long dismissed as the troubled trough of the Tudor century — a "mid-Tudor crisis" of weak rulers, fractured government, lurching religious reversals, economic distress, and serious popular rebellion. Two monarchs ruled in these years: Edward VI, a boy of nine who never reached his majority and died at fifteen; and Mary I, England's first crowned queen regnant, whose Catholic restoration and burning of Protestants earned her the enduring soubriquet "Bloody Mary." Real power lay first with two successive quasi-regents — the Dukes of Somerset and Northumberland — and the period saw the rapid alternation of state religion from the conservative Catholicism of Henry's last years, to the radical Protestantism of Edward's, to the restored Roman Catholicism of Mary's.
Yet whether "crisis" is the right word is one of the most important historiographical questions in the option. An older view (associated with W.R.D. Jones) saw a near-systemic breakdown. A powerful revisionist current — Jennifer Loach, Robert Tittler, David Loades — has argued that the institutions of government continued to function, that both Edwardian and Marian regimes pursued genuine and competent reform, and that the orderly succession of three monarchs in eleven years is hardly the mark of a state in collapse. This lesson examines the politics, religion, rebellions, and foreign policy of the period and equips you to weigh the "crisis" thesis against its revisionist critics.
Key Question: Was the mid-Tudor period a genuine "crisis" — a systemic failure of government, religion, economy, and foreign policy — or a difficult but ultimately survivable interlude in which the Tudor state, far from breaking down, proved its resilience and even laid constructive foundations for the Elizabethan age?
This lesson straddles the boundary of Paper 1 (Breadth), Option 1C, closing Part One ("Consolidation of the Tudor dynasty, 1485–1547") and opening Part Two ("England: turmoil and triumph, 1547–1603").
Edward VI was nine years old at his accession on 28 January 1547. Henry VIII's will had provided for a balanced Regency Council, but within days the king's maternal uncle, Edward Seymour, Earl of Hertford, had outmanoeuvred his colleagues, secured the title Duke of Somerset and Lord Protector, and concentrated power in his own hands.
| Aspect | Detail |
|---|---|
| Title and position | Lord Protector of the Realm and Governor of the King's Person; he increasingly bypassed the Council and ruled through his own household, alienating fellow councillors |
| Character | Idealistic but high-handed, arrogant, and politically maladroit; styled himself the "Good Duke," a champion of the poor |
| Scottish policy | Won the Battle of Pinkie (10 September 1547) but the attempt to garrison Scotland and force the marriage of Edward to Mary Queen of Scots (the "Rough Wooing") was ruinously expensive and counter-productive — it drove the Scots into the arms of France, who took the infant Mary to be raised there as bride to the Dauphin |
| Religious policy | A cautious but real move toward Protestantism |
| Social policy | Genuine sympathy for the rural poor; he backed enclosure commissions under John Hales (1548–49) — a stance that raised expectations he could not satisfy and arguably encouraged the unrest of 1549 |
| Reform | Detail |
|---|---|
| Repeal of the Six Articles (1547) | Swept away Henry's conservative heresy legislation, opening the door to reform |
| Chantries Act (1547) | Dissolved the chantries, confiscating endowments funding masses for the dead — both a revenue grab and a doctrinal blow at purgatory |
| First Book of Common Prayer (1549) | Imposed by the Act of Uniformity (1549); replaced the Latin Mass with an English liturgy, largely Cranmer's work, but deliberately ambiguous on the Eucharist to soften the change |
| Clerical marriage permitted (1549) | Reversed the celibacy rule — a clear Protestant reform |
| Removal of images | Injunctions ordered the destruction of "superstitious" images, candles, and ceremonies |
Key Definition: A chantry was an endowment funding a priest to say masses for the souls of the founder and their kin, hastening them through purgatory. Their dissolution under the Chantries Act (1547) was simultaneously a fiscal measure (raising substantial sums, though many endowments funded schools and almshouses that were also lost) and a doctrinal one — a public repudiation of purgatory, the theological engine of late-medieval Catholic piety.
The new English liturgy provoked open rebellion in the conservative far South-West.
| Aspect | Detail |
|---|---|
| Cause | The Prayer Book was imposed on Whitsunday (9 June) 1549; in Cornwall many parishioners spoke Cornish, not English, and across Devon and Cornwall the assault on the Latin Mass and traditional ceremony was bitterly resented |
| Demands | Restoration of the Latin Mass, the Act of Six Articles, communion in one kind, and traditional ceremonies; the rebels famously derided the new English service as "but like a Christmas game" |
| Scale | Perhaps 6,000 rebels besieged Exeter for several weeks |
| Suppression | Lord Russell, reinforced by foreign mercenaries, broke the rebellion; thousands were killed in the fighting and reprisals |
| Significance | The clearest demonstration that religious change "from above" could provoke violent popular resistance — the Western Rising was overwhelmingly religious in motivation, the mirror-image of Kett's economic rising |
Simultaneously, a very different and even larger rebellion erupted in Norfolk.
| Aspect | Detail |
|---|---|
| Leader | Robert Kett, a prosperous tanner and minor landowner — himself a man of property who turned against his own class's abuses |
| Cause | Overwhelmingly economic and agrarian: enclosure, overstocking of commons, rack-renting, and the abuse of manorial ("foldcourse") rights by landlords |
| Character | Strikingly orderly: the rebels held their own courts under the "Oak of Reformation," maintained discipline, and sought legal redress and good governance, not the overthrow of the social order |
| Scale | Perhaps 16,000 rebels encamped on Mousehold Heath above Norwich and took the city |
| Demands | The Mousehold Articles (29 articles): curbs on enclosure and gentry exploitation, reform of corrupt local officials, and protection of tenant rights |
| Suppression | The Earl of Warwick (John Dudley) crushed the camp at the Battle of Dussindale (August 1549) with professional troops including foreign mercenaries; Kett was hanged at Norwich Castle |
Exam Tip: The twin risings of 1549 exposed Somerset's fundamental weakness. His public sympathy for anti-enclosure grievances (the Hales commissions) raised hopes he could not meet and made him appear complicit in disorder, while his slowness to repress alarmed the propertied classes. Diarmaid MacCulloch argues that Somerset's well-meaning populism actively encouraged rebellion by signalling that the regime shared the commons' complaints. It was this loss of elite confidence, more than the rebellions themselves, that brought him down in October 1549.
John Dudley, Earl of Warwick (created Duke of Northumberland in 1551), engineered Somerset's fall in October 1549 and emerged as the effective head of government — a far abler, if less likeable, ruler than his predecessor.
| Aspect | Somerset | Northumberland |
|---|---|---|
| Title | Lord Protector | Lord President of the Council — pointedly avoiding the provocative "Protector" and ruling through the Council, restoring at least the form of conciliar government |
| Style | Idealistic, populist, autocratic in practice | Pragmatic, efficient, ruthless, politically astute |
| Finance | Reckless war spending; further debasement of the coinage | Withdrew from the costly Scottish and French wars; began to restore the currency and reform the revenue courts (work that benefited Mary and Elizabeth) |
| Religion | Cautious, incremental Protestantism | More thoroughly and doctrinally Protestant |
| Reputation | Sympathetically remembered as the "Good Duke" | Long vilified as a self-serving villain (the Jane Grey coup) — but substantially rehabilitated by revisionists who credit his administrative competence |
| Reform | Detail |
|---|---|
| Second Book of Common Prayer (1552) | Decisively Protestant: the communion is framed as a memorial, and the so-called Black Rubric denied any "real and essential presence" of Christ's natural body in the sacrament |
| Forty-Two Articles (1553) | A fully Protestant confession of faith drafted chiefly by Cranmer; the doctrinal high-water mark of the English Reformation to date (later the basis of Elizabeth's Thirty-Nine Articles) |
| Ordinal (1550) | A reformed rite for ordaining clergy, stripped of Catholic sacrificial language |
| Stripping of churches | Stone altars replaced by wooden communion tables; removal of images, plate, and vestments — the visible Protestantising of the parish church |
By Edward's death the Church of England was, on paper, a fully Reformed Protestant institution. How deeply this had penetrated popular belief in only six years is doubtful — a point the revisionists (Haigh, Duffy) press hard, and which helps explain the relative ease of Mary's Catholic restoration.
As the consumptive Edward VI lay dying in the spring of 1553 (aged fifteen), the Protestant succession itself came into question, since the heir by Henry VIII's will and the Act of Succession was the Catholic Mary.
| Aspect | Detail |
|---|---|
| Edward's "Devise for the Succession" | The dying king — a sincere and zealous Protestant — drafted a device excluding both his half-sisters (Mary and Elizabeth) as illegitimate, and settling the crown on his cousin Lady Jane Grey, a committed Protestant |
| Northumberland's role | Northumberland married his son Lord Guildford Dudley to Jane and promoted the scheme — but it is now widely accepted that the initiative came substantially from Edward himself, not solely from an ambitious Duke |
| Jane's "reign" | Jane was proclaimed queen on 10 July 1553; her reign lasted just nine days (often counted as thirteen) |
| Mary's response | Mary fled to East Anglia, proclaimed herself queen at Framlingham, and rallied overwhelming support — crucially from Catholics and Protestants who upheld the legitimate Tudor line; the Privy Council promptly defected to her |
| Outcome | Northumberland's support evaporated; he was arrested and executed (August 1553). Jane was initially spared but executed in February 1554 in the aftermath of Wyatt's Rebellion |
The significance of 1553 cuts against the "crisis" thesis: a usurping attempt backed by the head of government collapsed almost bloodlessly because the country rallied to the legitimate heir. Far from demonstrating the fragility of the Tudor state, it demonstrated the strength of dynastic loyalty and the resilience of the succession.
Mary I's reign is among the most fiercely contested in Tudor historiography — caricatured for centuries as a sterile reign of fanatical persecution, but substantially reassessed by modern scholars.
| Reform | Detail |
|---|---|
| Repeal of Edwardian legislation | The first statute of repeal (1553) undid the Edwardian Reformation, restoring the religion of Henry VIII's last years; the second (1554) restored papal obedience |
| Reconciliation with Rome | Cardinal Reginald Pole returned as papal legate in November 1554 and formally absolved the realm; Pole became Archbishop of Canterbury after Cranmer's deprivation |
| Heresy laws revived | The medieval statutes against heresy (including De heretico comburendo) were restored, providing the legal basis for the burnings |
| Monastic lands NOT restored | Crucially, Mary accepted that the dissolved monastic lands could not be reclaimed: the gentry and nobility who had bought them would not surrender them, and Pole and Mary recognised that to demand it would shatter the regime's support. Only token refoundations (e.g. Westminster) occurred |
The point about monastic land is the most analytically important feature of the restoration: it demonstrates the irreversibility built into the Henrician settlement by the land sales (Lesson 3). Even a Catholic queen restoring the Pope could not undo the material facts of the Reformation.
Subscribe to continue reading
Get full access to this lesson and all 10 lessons in this course.