You are viewing a free preview of this lesson.
Subscribe to unlock all 10 lessons in this course and every other course on LearningBro.
The medieval period — roughly the fifth to the fifteenth century — saw Christianity become the dominant cultural, intellectual and political force in Europe. Monasticism shaped education, agriculture and learning; scholastic theology produced some of the most sophisticated thought in history; the papacy reached the height of its temporal power; the Great Schism of 1054 divided East from West; and the Crusades entangled faith with conquest. This lesson examines monasticism and the friars, scholasticism (Anselm and Aquinas), the power of the papacy, the East–West schism, the Crusades, and the sacramental and penitential theology that structured ordinary Christian life.
Christian monasticism — the pursuit of holiness through withdrawal from the world, prayer and ascetic discipline — has its roots in the Desert Fathers and Mothers of third- and fourth-century Egypt. Its rise is connected to the changed situation of the Church after Constantine: once martyrdom was no longer the likely cost of faith, the ascetic life of renunciation came to be seen as a kind of "white martyrdom", a total self-offering to God in place of the "red martyrdom" of blood. Antony of Egypt (c. AD 251–356) is traditionally regarded as the father of monasticism; his withdrawal into the desert for a life of prayer, fasting and spiritual struggle, recorded in a Life attributed to Athanasius, became hugely influential. Alongside the solitary (eremitic) life of hermits such as Antony developed the communal (cenobitic) life, organised by Pachomius in Egypt, in which monks lived together under a common rule. But it was Benedict of Nursia (c. AD 480–547) who gave Western monasticism its enduring shape.
Benedict's Rule (c. AD 530) became the foundational document of Western monastic life, prized for its moderation and good sense. It organised the common life around three principles:
Benedictine monasteries became centres of learning, agriculture and civilisation. Monks copied and preserved classical and Christian texts, ran schools and infirmaries, and offered hospitality to travellers; the Carolingian Renaissance of the eighth and ninth centuries drew heavily on Benedictine scholarship.
Key term: Lectio divina — "divine reading", the slow, meditative reading of Scripture, traditionally in four movements: lectio (reading), meditatio (meditation), oratio (prayer) and contemplatio (contemplation).
In the thirteenth century two new orders of friars (from Latin frater, "brother") transformed the Church. Unlike enclosed monks, friars were mendicant — they lived by begging and moved through the towns, preaching to ordinary people.
Francis of Assisi (c. 1181–1226) founded the Order of Friars Minor (Franciscans), receiving papal approval for his way of life around 1209–10. The son of a prosperous cloth merchant, Francis renounced his inheritance for a life of radical poverty in identification with the poor. The movement was marked by:
Dominic de Guzmán (c. 1170–1221) founded the Order of Preachers (Dominicans), approved in 1216, dedicated to combating heresy — especially the Cathars of southern France — through preaching and learning. The Dominicans combined poverty with rigorous study and produced some of the greatest theologians of the age, including Albert the Great and Thomas Aquinas.
The friars represented a genuine innovation in religious life. Where the older monastic ideal was stability — remaining in one community — the friars were mobile, going where the need was greatest, and they deliberately based themselves in the growing towns and universities rather than in remote rural monasteries. This made them ideally suited to the new urban and intellectual conditions of the thirteenth century. They preached to ordinary people in the vernacular, heard confessions, and engaged the leading ideas of the day. Their arrival was not universally welcomed — the established clergy and the older orders sometimes resented these energetic newcomers — but the friars rapidly became one of the most dynamic forces in the medieval Church, embodying a fresh attempt to live the gospel of poverty and to bring it into contact with the realities of town and university life.
Aquinas himself exemplifies the Dominican synthesis of poverty, prayer and learning. Born to a noble Italian family who opposed his joining the friars (they are said to have held him captive for a time to dissuade him), he studied under Albert the Great, taught at Paris and elsewhere, and produced an astonishing body of work before his death in 1274 — including the unfinished Summa Theologiae. Late in life he had an experience in prayer after which he ceased writing, reportedly saying that all he had written seemed to him "like straw" compared with what he had seen. The remark captures something of the relationship between the scholastic and mystical strands: even the greatest of the schoolmen acknowledged that the reality of God exceeds all that reason can articulate.
Scholasticism was the dominant intellectual method of the medieval cathedral schools and universities (Paris, Oxford, Bologna). It applied careful logical analysis to questions of faith and sought to reconcile Christian belief with classical philosophy — above all the philosophy of Aristotle, whose works re-entered the Latin West through Arabic and Greek transmission in the twelfth and thirteenth centuries.
Anselm of Canterbury (c. 1033–1109) is often called the "father of scholasticism". His programme of fides quaerens intellectum — "faith seeking understanding" — held that the believer reasons from faith toward understanding. He is remembered for two great contributions:
The greatest scholastic theologian was Thomas Aquinas (c. 1225–1274), a Dominican friar whose Summa Theologiae remains one of the most important works in Christian thought. Central features of his theology include:
Key term: Scholasticism — the method of theological and philosophical inquiry dominant in the medieval schools, marked by rigorous logical analysis, the use of Aristotelian categories, and the project of reconciling faith with reason.
The scholastic enterprise was not without internal controversy. Peter Abelard (1079–1142), a brilliant and combative master in Paris, pioneered the dialectical method in his Sic et Non ("Yes and No"), which juxtaposed apparently conflicting statements from the Church Fathers to train students to reconcile them through careful distinction. His emphasis on reason and his controversial views drew the fierce opposition of the more traditional and mystical Bernard of Clairvaux, who had him condemned — a clash that dramatises the tension between dialectical reason and contemplative faith in the twelfth century. A further great debate concerned universals: whether general terms such as "humanity" name real entities (realism) or are merely names or concepts (nominalism). This was no mere logical puzzle, for it bore on how language about God and the sacraments could function. The later medieval turn toward nominalism, associated with William of Ockham (c. 1287 – c. 1347), with his principle of parsimony ("Ockham's razor"), and his stress on the freedom of the divine will, helped reshape the intellectual landscape in the centuries before the Reformation.
The deepest issue running through scholasticism was the relationship between faith and reason. Anselm's fides quaerens intellectum and Aquinas's confidence that reason and revelation cannot conflict represented an optimistic synthesis. But the rediscovery of Aristotle also provoked alarm: some of Aristotle's positions (the eternity of the world, a remote God) seemed to contradict Christian doctrine, and a movement sometimes called "Latin Averroism" was accused of holding that something could be true in philosophy yet false in theology. The Condemnations of 1277 at Paris, which censured a list of propositions drawn partly from Aristotle, show the Church anxiously policing the boundary. Aquinas's achievement was to "baptise" Aristotle — to show that a Christianised Aristotelianism could serve rather than threaten the faith — and his synthesis became, especially after his canonisation, the benchmark of Catholic theology.
For the AQA student, Aquinas is not merely a medieval figure but a thinker whose work underpins several topics across the specification. His cosmological argument — specifically the Third Way, from the contingency of the world to a necessary being — is a set text in the philosophy of religion, criticised by later thinkers such as Hume and Russell. His theory of natural law, the view that there is a moral order accessible to reason and grounded in human nature and ultimately in God's eternal law, is one of the principal normative theories in religious ethics, with its precepts, the principle of double effect, and its application to issues such as lying and the taking of life. His doctrine of analogy addresses the problem of religious language — how words drawn from creaturely experience can meaningfully be applied to God. Recognising that the medieval scholastic project is the source of these later debates helps the student see the continuity between "Christian history" and the philosophical and ethical components of the course.
It is difficult for modern students to grasp how comprehensively the Church shaped medieval life. There was no separation of "religious" and "secular" spheres: the Church baptised, married and buried; it ran the schools and universities; it cared for the sick and the poor through monasteries and hospitals; it provided the calendar of feasts and fasts that ordered the year; and it offered, through the sacraments, the means of grace from cradle to grave. The parish church was the centre of the community, and the great cathedrals — Chartres, Canterbury, Cologne — were collective acts of devotion that took generations to build. Pilgrimage to shrines such as Santiago de Compostela or the tomb of Thomas Becket at Canterbury was a major feature of popular religion. This all-encompassing role gave the medieval Church enormous influence for good — and, as critics stress, enormous scope for the abuse of power, wealth and superstition that the reformers would later attack.
The sacrament of penance deserves particular attention, because it lay at the heart of medieval religious anxiety and would become the flashpoint of the Reformation. The Church taught that, while baptism washed away original sin, sins committed afterwards required confession to a priest, contrition, absolution and the performance of satisfaction. Behind this lay the distinction between eternal punishment (remitted by absolution) and temporal punishment (to be worked off through penance in this life or in purgatory). Indulgences offered remission of this temporal punishment, drawing on the "treasury of merit". The whole system gave structure and assurance to the spiritual life — there was a clear path back to grace after sin — but it also generated profound fear of purgatory and judgement, and it created the conditions in which the sale of indulgences could flourish. When Luther attacked indulgences in 1517, he was striking at the most sensitive nerve of medieval popular religion.
The medieval centuries saw the papacy claim — and often exercise — supreme authority not only in spiritual but in temporal affairs. The Investiture Controversy of the eleventh and twelfth centuries was a struggle between popes and secular rulers over the right to appoint (or "invest") bishops and abbots. It reached a dramatic point in the clash between Pope Gregory VII and the Emperor Henry IV, who in 1077 famously did penance in the snow at Canossa to have his excommunication lifted. Under Innocent III (pope 1198–1216) papal authority reached its height; he asserted the pope's right to intervene in the affairs of kingdoms and convened the Fourth Lateran Council (1215), which legislated for the whole Western Church and gave the term transubstantiation official standing.
Subscribe to continue reading
Get full access to this lesson and all 10 lessons in this course.