You are viewing a free preview of this lesson.
Subscribe to unlock all 10 lessons in this course and every other course on LearningBro.
Every previous lesson has built a piece of the method. This final lesson runs the full method in real time against a single simulated exam scenario, so you can see how each decision feeds the next. You will watch a Grade 9 response emerge from the question paper stage by stage: reading, planning, writing, proofreading. The clock is tracked throughout.
Because this is a walkthrough, the poems and prompt are invented, but they are written in the register and length of real Edexcel unseens. Read the poems once before the walkthrough begins.
"Compare the ways the writers present memory in both poems. In your answer, you should consider the writers' use of language, form and structure."
It was always on, that bright tinny voice, the pop songs tumbling from the shelf above the tea. My mother hummed along without the words, her hands in flour, her eyes somewhere else.
I remember the radio more than her face, the chipped yellow dial, the wire loose in the back, the way the kitchen held its breath through the news and let it out again when the music came back.
Now I switch on my own kitchen, my own bright voice, and there she is — humming between the bars, her hands in flour somewhere in the static, still not quite reaching the words.
I open the box and the years tip out: a beach, a dog, a birthday, a leaf. Each one a small, flat door I cannot walk through.
Here is my grandmother in a coat I never saw her wear. Here is a house that must have been hers. Here is a hand, cut off at the wrist.
I try to arrange them by date but the dates lie; the paper remembers what I do not.
I close the box. The years do not go back in.
At the clock's 00:00, your pen is down. You read Poem A once, eyes only. Then Poem B. Each takes about thirty seconds.
Read 1 summary, Poem A: A speaker remembers the radio that was always on while their mother baked; the radio lingers in memory more vividly than the mother's face. When the speaker uses their own radio now, the mother seems to return — still indistinct, still reaching for words she never quite finds.
Read 1 summary, Poem B: A speaker opens a box of photographs. They cannot truly enter any of the images; the photos are recognisable but also strange. The paper's record does not match the speaker's memory. The box is closed and the years do not "go back in".
Both poems frame memory as partial, resistant, and mediated by objects — a radio in one, photographs in the other.
You now pen up for Read 2. Annotate Poem A:
Annotate Poem B:
Read 3: both poems side by side. Both use objects to structure memory (radio / photos). Both struggle with return: the speaker in Poem A finds a partial return; the speaker in Poem B refuses return altogether. Both use personification of the object (the kitchen holds its breath; the paper remembers). Arrows drawn between these correspondences.
You glance at the clock: 03:00.
You turn to a quiet corner of the question paper and draw a grid.
| Poem A (Radio) | Poem B (Photos) | |
|---|---|---|
| Language | Personification of kitchen "held its breath"; metaphor of mother "humming between the bars" — music as soft captivity | Extended metaphor of photos as "small, flat door I cannot walk through"; personification "the paper remembers what I do not" |
| Form | Three quatrains, loosely regular, rhythm loosens over the poem | Free verse, irregular stanzas shortening toward two-line close |
| Structure | Begins in past, moves to present; circular return via the radio | Begins with opening, ends with closing; action frames the poem, but no return |
Now the overview sentence, drafted at the top of the answer page:
Both poems stage memory as an encounter with an object — a radio in the first, a box of photographs in the second — but where Poem A allows the object to deliver a fragile, partial return to the remembered person, Poem B insists that the object is a door the speaker cannot walk through, and the poem closes without readmitting the past.
Clock: 06:00.
Pen to answer page. You write:
Both poems personify the objects through which memory arrives, but with opposed emotional consequences. In Poem A, the kitchen "held its breath through the news / and let it out again when the music came back"; the personification extends to the whole room, so that the domestic space becomes complicit in the ritual, holding and releasing tension alongside the family. Memory, in this image, is shared between body and architecture. By contrast, Poem B personifies the paper itself — "the paper remembers what I do not" — but the personification is adversarial: the object holds a memory the speaker has lost, and the photograph's record competes with, rather than supports, the rememberer. Where Poem A's object breathes with the speaker, Poem B's object testifies against them.
(Paragraph roughly 115 words, two quotations, two techniques, clear bridge.)
Clock: approximately 11:00.
The two poems also present memory through opposed formal strategies. Poem A uses three loose quatrains — not strictly metrical, but patterned enough to feel contained — and the stanza boundaries move the reader from past ("It was always on"), to remembered past ("I remember the radio more than her face"), to reconfigured present ("Now I switch on my own kitchen"). The regularity of the stanza count acts as a container that permits memory to circulate without spilling. Poem B refuses such containment: its stanzas are of uneven length — four lines, three, three, two — and the visible contraction toward the two-line close ("I close the box. / The years do not go back in.") enacts the shrinking possibility of return. Where Poem A's form holds memory like the kitchen holding its breath, Poem B's form itself closes down.
(Paragraph roughly 140 words; you are slightly over budget but paragraph is tight.)
Clock: approximately 16:30.
Slightly behind; you tighten the paragraph.
Subscribe to continue reading
Get full access to this lesson and all 10 lessons in this course.