You are viewing a free preview of this lesson.
Subscribe to unlock all 10 lessons in this course and every other course on LearningBro.
Between 1934 and 1938 the Soviet Union underwent a campaign of state violence against its own elite that had no precedent in modern European history. Members of the Politburo, the Central Committee, the army high command, the security services, the industrial bureaucracy, the Comintern and the wider party apparatus were arrested, tried, and in most cases executed or dispatched to the Gulag. Approximately 700,000 executions were recorded in 1937–38 in the surviving NKVD archive; some historians argue for a figure closer to one million. The Gulag population rose to approximately 1.5 million prisoners by 1939. Stalin's purges consolidated personal rule through selective terror; they also inflicted lasting damage on the military and economic competence of the Soviet state, losses that would be felt when Germany attacked in June 1941. This lesson traces the sequence of trials, the mechanics of the Great Terror, the military purge of 1937, the Gulag, the reasons advanced by historians, the consequences, and the construction of the Stalinist Cult of Personality.
The show trials of 1936–38 were not the first. The methodology — public prosecution of named defendants for political conspiracy, supported by detailed confessions — had been tested through the late 1920s and early 1930s.
These trials normalised a method — political prosecution, confession-based evidence, press mobilisation — that would be applied on a larger scale after 1934.
On the afternoon of 1 December 1934, Sergei Kirov, First Secretary of the Leningrad Party organisation and a full member of the Politburo, was shot in the corridor of the Smolny Institute by a discontented former party member, Leonid Nikolaev. Kirov had been one of the most popular speakers at the Seventeenth Party Congress ("Congress of Victors") earlier that year; unconfirmed accounts suggest that a substantial bloc of delegates had voted against Stalin in the Central Committee ballot and in favour of Kirov.
Whether Stalin ordered the murder remains debated. Robert Conquest, in The Great Terror (1968), argued that the circumstances — the NKVD's removal of Kirov's bodyguard, the unusual access granted to Nikolaev, the rapid execution of witnesses — pointed to Stalin's direct involvement. Later archival work (J. Arch Getty, Oleg Khlevniuk) has been more cautious, suggesting that Nikolaev may have acted alone and that Stalin seized on the crime rather than ordering it.
What is not in doubt is the use Stalin made of the murder. Within hours a Decree on Terrorist Acts was promulgated: investigations in cases of "terrorism" were to be completed within ten days, trials were to proceed without defence counsel and without appeal, and death sentences were to be carried out immediately. This legal framework governed the arrests that followed. By the end of 1935 Zinoviev and Kamenev had been arrested in connection with the "Leningrad centre" said to lie behind the murder; both received prison sentences. The path to the show trials was open.
Three major show trials were staged in Moscow between August 1936 and March 1938. All were prosecuted by Andrei Vyshinsky, Prosecutor-General of the USSR, whose rhetorical style ("Shoot the mad dogs!") set the courtroom register. All ended in confessions and, in almost every case, execution.
| Trial | Date | Principal defendants | Charges | Outcome |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Trial of the Sixteen ("Trotskyite-Zinovievite Terrorist Centre") | 19–24 August 1936 | Zinoviev, Kamenev, 14 others | Conspiracy with Trotsky to murder Kirov and Stalin | All 16 condemned; all shot, 25 August 1936 |
| Trial of the Seventeen ("Parallel Anti-Soviet Trotskyite Centre") | 23–30 January 1937 | Pyatakov, Radek, 15 others | Industrial sabotage, collaboration with Germany and Japan | 13 shot; 4 (including Radek) to Gulag (Radek killed 1939) |
| Trial of the Twenty-One ("Bloc of Rightists and Trotskyites") | 2–13 March 1938 | Bukharin, Rykov, Yagoda, 18 others | Conspiracy to restore capitalism; murder of Kirov and Gorky | 18 shot (including Bukharin, Rykov, Yagoda); 3 to Gulag |
The confessions were elaborate and internally consistent; they were extracted by a combination of prolonged interrogation, sleep deprivation, threats against the defendants' families and, in some cases, explicit promises of leniency in exchange for full confession. They were often retracted in private moments — Bukharin in his last letter to Stalin; several of the accused to foreign observers in the courtroom — and the evidentiary detail in the public record was frequently incompatible with outside chronology (defendants were accused of meetings in hotels that had been demolished, or of flights to airports that did not exist). But the political effect did not depend on forensic plausibility. The trials removed the last survivors of Lenin's Politburo from the political stage and from subsequent memory. With Bukharin's execution in March 1938, the "Old Bolsheviks" who had led the party before 1917 were gone.
Outside the courtroom, the Great Terror was a mass operation administered by the NKVD (People's Commissariat for Internal Affairs) according to quotas issued from the centre. The principal instrument was NKVD Order No. 00447 of 30 July 1937, which specified for every region of the Soviet Union a number of "former kulaks, criminals and other anti-Soviet elements" to be processed in "first category" (execution) and "second category" (8–10 years in the Gulag). The initial national target was 75,950 executions and 193,000 camp sentences; it was repeatedly increased on regional request.
Under Nikolai Yezhov, head of the NKVD from September 1936, the operation became known as the Yezhovshchina ("the Yezhov time"). Yezhov's NKVD processed cases in extraordinary troika panels — three officials sitting outside normal judicial procedure — and operated arrest quotas that local officials met by denunciation campaigns and pre-emptive lists. The category "enemy of the people" (vrag naroda) was a legal formulation in this period: accusation carried the presumption of guilt, and the families of those arrested were themselves subject to arrest, deportation or the removal of children to state orphanages.
Parallel mass operations targeted national minorities: the "Polish Operation" of 1937–38 arrested approximately 140,000 people of Polish nationality or ancestry, of whom approximately 111,000 were shot; similar "national operations" affected ethnic Germans, Latvians, Finns, Koreans, and Chinese communities in the Far East. The geography of arrest in the Terror followed the geography of suspicion as much as the geography of plot.
Yezhov himself was arrested in April 1939 and shot in February 1940; he was replaced in December 1938 by Lavrentiy Beria, a Georgian security chief who had supervised the purges in the Caucasus. Beria presided over a modest release of those whose cases had not yet been processed and over a reduction in the tempo of arrest — a pattern of "correction" that itself became part of Stalinist technique, blaming excesses on the subordinate while preserving the main result.
flowchart TD
A[Kirov murder 1 Dec 1934] --> B[Decree on Terrorist Acts]
B --> C[Trial of the Sixteen<br/>Aug 1936<br/>Zinoviev, Kamenev]
C --> D[Yezhov heads NKVD<br/>Sept 1936]
D --> E[Trial of the Seventeen<br/>Jan 1937<br/>Pyatakov, Radek]
D --> F[Military purge June 1937<br/>Tukhachevsky + 7]
D --> G[NKVD Order 00447<br/>30 July 1937<br/>mass operation]
G --> H[~700,000 executions 1937-38]
E --> I[Trial of the Twenty-One<br/>March 1938<br/>Bukharin, Rykov, Yagoda]
F --> I
I --> J[Beria replaces Yezhov<br/>Dec 1938]
J --> K[Gulag ~1.5m prisoners by 1939]
The military purge was compressed into a single catastrophic operation.
On the night of 11–12 June 1937, Marshal Mikhail Tukhachevsky, Deputy Commissar for Defence and chief theorist of the Red Army's mechanised doctrine, was tried in camera with seven other senior commanders: Yakir, Uborevich, Kork, Eideman, Feldman, Primakov and Putna. The trial lasted a single day; all eight were shot the same night.
The Tukhachevsky group was the apex of a wider operation. In the eighteen months that followed, approximately 35,000 Red Army officers were arrested. The toll at the top was extraordinary:
The operation destroyed, in a single year, the generation of Red Army commanders who had absorbed the lessons of the Civil War and had been developing the doctrine of "deep operations" — the Soviet theory of combined-arms offensive that in the late 1930s was a decade ahead of anything in the French or British armies. The commanders who replaced them were junior, often politically trusted but professionally inexperienced, and the institutional memory of the 1920s and early 1930s was lost. The costs would be paid in the Winter War against Finland (1939–40) and catastrophically in the first months of the German invasion in June 1941.
The military purge had significant international consequences. Evidence (fabricated or genuine) of Tukhachevsky's supposed contacts with the German General Staff was circulated by both the NKVD and the Nazi security service; the purge appeared to confirm to Western military attachés that the Red Army was of poor quality, a perception that shaped Anglo-French strategy through 1939.
The Gulag — an acronym for the Main Administration of Camps (Glavnoye Upravleniye Lagerey) — was the NKVD agency responsible for the Soviet penal labour system. The camp network expanded with collectivisation in 1930–32, again with the Kirov arrests in 1934–35, and reached its first peak during the Great Terror.
Subscribe to continue reading
Get full access to this lesson and all 10 lessons in this course.