You are viewing a free preview of this lesson.
Subscribe to unlock all 10 lessons in this course and every other course on LearningBro.
In the winter of 1916–17 the Russian Empire, the largest and in some respects the most backward of the Great Powers, was entering its third winter of war with Germany and Austria-Hungary. Within the space of eight months the three-hundred-year-old Romanov dynasty had collapsed, a liberal-socialist Provisional Government had replaced it, and the Bolshevik Party — a Marxist faction that in February 1917 had fewer than 25,000 members — had seized power in Petrograd. This lesson examines the structural weaknesses of tsarist Russia in 1914, the impact of the First World War, the February Revolution of 1917, the period of Dual Power, and the reasons for the Bolshevik success in October. It is treated as a single compressed event, because the two revolutions are best understood as two phases of the same crisis: the collapse of tsarism and the subsequent collapse of the liberal alternative that tried to replace it.
Russia on the eve of war was ruled by Tsar Nicholas II, who had come to the throne in 1894. His authority rested on the doctrine of autocracy — the belief that the tsar held unlimited power by divine right. After the 1905 Revolution Nicholas had reluctantly conceded a representative assembly, the Duma, but its powers were repeatedly curtailed, and by 1914 the Duma was dominated by loyalist parties and regarded by the liberal Kadets and moderate socialists as a consultative ornament rather than a genuine legislature.
Beneath the thin layer of court, bureaucracy and army officers stretched a vast rural society. Roughly 80 per cent of the population were peasants, living in communes (mir) and practising near-subsistence agriculture; literacy was around 40 per cent; life expectancy barely touched 30 years in the worst provinces. The Stolypin reforms of 1906–11 had attempted to create a class of prosperous independent farmers (the kulaks) as a bulwark against revolution, but by 1914 only a minority of peasants had left the commune. The peasant question — who owned the land, and on what terms — remained the unresolved political problem of the empire.
Industrialisation, by contrast, had advanced rapidly since the 1890s under finance ministers Witte and Kokovtsov. By 1914 Russia had Europe's fourth-largest industrial economy in absolute terms, concentrated in a few centres: St Petersburg (renamed Petrograd in August 1914), Moscow, the Donbas coalfields, Baku oil, and the Urals. These modern factories produced a comparatively small but highly politicised industrial proletariat, more than half of whom worked in plants of over a thousand workers — a concentration that made strike action and revolutionary organisation unusually effective.
| Feature | Russia 1914 |
|---|---|
| Population | c. 166 million |
| Peasants | c. 80% |
| Industrial workforce | c. 3.5 million |
| Literacy | c. 40% (male), lower for women |
| Form of government | Autocracy with restricted Duma |
| Main political parties | Kadets (liberal), SRs (peasant socialists), Mensheviks, Bolsheviks |
The regime's structural weakness was that it rested on a narrow social base — army, church, landowners, bureaucracy — while the two largest social groups (peasants and workers) had legitimate grievances that autocracy could neither admit nor address without dismantling itself.
When Russia entered the war in August 1914 it did so in a mood of patriotic unity, but the unity lasted barely a year. The empire mobilised more than 15 million men over the course of the conflict, of whom approximately 2 million were dead by early 1917 and a similar number had been taken prisoner. Battlefield defeats (Tannenberg, the Masurian Lakes, the Great Retreat of 1915) were compounded by shortages of rifles, artillery shells and boots.
In September 1915 Nicholas took personal command of the armed forces at Stavka, the front-line headquarters. The decision was politically catastrophic. It associated the tsar directly with every subsequent military setback, and it left government in Petrograd in the hands of his wife, Empress Alexandra, and her circle. Alexandra's reliance on the Siberian mystic Grigori Rasputin — whose supposed healing of the haemophiliac Tsarevich Alexei had given him extraordinary access at court — generated rumours of espionage, sexual scandal and German sympathy that were hugely corrosive of the dynasty's authority. Rasputin was murdered by aristocratic conspirators in December 1916, an act that revealed the regime's loss of support even among its natural defenders.
The war also produced economic collapse on the home front. Railways, prioritising military traffic, failed to deliver grain to the cities; inflation eroded urban wages; and by the winter of 1916–17 Petrograd was receiving only a third of the flour it required. Strikes, almost unknown in 1914, affected more than a million workers by January 1917. The regime faced a crisis of supply, a crisis of legitimacy and a crisis of military performance simultaneously.
The February Revolution was not planned. It began on International Women's Day, 23 February (Julian) / 8 March (Gregorian) 1917, when women textile workers in the Vyborg district of Petrograd walked out over bread shortages. Over the next four days strikes spread through the capital, reaching 200,000 workers by 25 February. On 26 February Nicholas, from Stavka, ordered the Petrograd garrison to suppress the demonstrations. On 27 February the Volynsky Regiment mutinied rather than fire on civilians, and other units followed. The Cossacks, traditionally the regime's shock troops against civil disturbance, declined to intervene. Without loyal troops in the capital, the autocracy had no instrument of coercion.
Two rival bodies filled the vacuum. In the Tauride Palace, Duma moderates formed a Provisional Committee under Prince Lvov; in a neighbouring room, striking workers and mutinous soldiers elected a Petrograd Soviet on the 1905 model. On the night of 2 March (O.S.) / 15 March (N.S.), a delegation of Duma politicians met Nicholas at Pskov; confronted by a telegram from his generals urging abdication, he signed away the throne for himself and for his son, nominating his brother Grand Duke Michael, who declined the crown the following day. The Romanov dynasty had ended in forty-eight hours.
| Date (Julian) | Event |
|---|---|
| 23 February | International Women's Day strikes in Petrograd |
| 25 February | General strike; c. 200,000 workers out |
| 27 February | Volynsky Regiment mutinies; Petrograd Soviet formed |
| 2 March | Nicholas II abdicates at Pskov |
| 3 March | Grand Duke Michael refuses the throne |
From March to October 1917, Russia was governed — or attempted to be governed — by two competing authorities operating from the same building.
flowchart TD
A[February Revolution] --> B[Provisional Government<br/>Lvov then Kerensky]
A --> C[Petrograd Soviet<br/>Mensheviks, SRs, later Bolsheviks]
B --> D[War continues; land reform postponed]
C --> E[Order No. 1: soldiers loyal to Soviet]
D --> F[Crisis of legitimacy]
E --> F
F --> G[October Revolution]
The Provisional Government's decision to continue the war was the single largest strategic error of 1917. It alienated peasant conscripts who wanted to go home and redistribute land, and industrial workers whose wages were being consumed by wartime inflation. The failed June Offensive, launched by Kerensky as War Minister, produced mass desertion and discredited the government further.
Vladimir Ilich Ulyanov (Lenin) had been in exile in Zurich when the tsar fell. On 3 April 1917 (O.S.) he arrived at the Finland Station in Petrograd, having been permitted by the German High Command to cross Germany in a sealed train on the calculation that he would destabilise Russia's war effort. The calculation proved correct.
Lenin's April Theses broke decisively with the mainstream Menshevik and SR view that Russia must first complete a bourgeois-democratic revolution before socialism could be contemplated. He demanded: no cooperation with the Provisional Government; an immediate end to the war; transfer of all power to the Soviets; nationalisation of land; and workers' control of production. The programme condensed into three slogans of extraordinary propaganda power: "Peace, Land, Bread" and "All Power to the Soviets".
In July 1917 mass demonstrations of workers, sailors and soldiers — the July Days — called on the Petrograd Soviet to take power. The Bolsheviks were ambivalent: they had helped to inspire the demonstrations but judged that the moment had not come. The rising collapsed, the government released documents accusing Lenin of being a German agent, and he fled to Finland. Trotsky was arrested. In the short term the July Days were a reverse for Bolshevism.
The turning point came in August. General Lavr Kornilov, the new Commander-in-Chief, ordered loyal troops towards Petrograd. Whether he intended a military coup against the Soviet or a coordinated move with Kerensky against the Bolsheviks is still debated. Kerensky, alarmed, denounced Kornilov as a counter-revolutionary and armed the Petrograd workers — including Bolshevik Red Guards — to defend the capital. The Kornilov Affair destroyed Kerensky's standing with the officer corps, armed the Bolsheviks' paramilitary base, and appeared to validate Lenin's claim that the Provisional Government was incapable of defending the revolution. By September the Bolsheviks held a majority in both the Petrograd and Moscow Soviets; Trotsky was elected chairman of the Petrograd Soviet.
The October Revolution was not a popular insurrection on the scale of February; it was a targeted seizure of key points by the Bolshevik-led Military Revolutionary Committee (MRC) of the Petrograd Soviet, under Trotsky's direction. Lenin, returning in disguise from Finland, pressed the Central Committee to act before the Second Congress of Soviets could open on 25 October. On the night of 24–25 October (Julian) / 6–7 November (Gregorian), Red Guards and sympathetic soldiers occupied the main telegraph office, railway stations, bridges and government buildings. The cruiser Aurora fired a blank shot at the Winter Palace. The Provisional Government's ministers were arrested in the early hours of 26 October; Kerensky escaped disguised in a car borrowed from the American embassy.
When the Second Congress of Soviets opened later that day, the Mensheviks and moderate SRs walked out in protest at what they called a Bolshevik coup. Trotsky's reply — "Go to the place where you belong from now on: the dustbin of history!" — captured the new regime's intransigence. The Congress ratified the seizure of power, accepted decrees on Peace and Land drafted by Lenin, and constituted a new government, the Council of People's Commissars (Sovnarkom), with Lenin as Chairman.
The reasons for Bolshevik success in October combine structural and contingent factors. It is useful to distinguish them in an analytical answer.
Exam Tip (Q5(c)/(d) — judgement): The question will ask how important one factor was, or whether a given factor was the main reason. You gain marks not for listing causes but for weighing them. A top-band answer argues that, for example, the Provisional Government's war policy was the underlying condition but that Lenin's decision to act in October was the decisive trigger — and supports each side with specific evidence.
This content is aligned with the Edexcel GCSE History (1HI0) Paper 3 Modern Depth Study specification.