You are viewing a free preview of this lesson.
Subscribe to unlock all 10 lessons in this course and every other course on LearningBro.
In November 1918, Germany stood at the edge of collapse. The First World War had ground on for more than four years, the blockade imposed by the Royal Navy had reduced much of the civilian population to hunger, and the spring 1918 Ludendorff Offensive had failed. Mutinies among sailors at Kiel spread into a revolution that forced Kaiser Wilhelm II to abdicate, and on 9 November the Social Democrat Philipp Scheidemann proclaimed a republic from a Reichstag balcony. The state that emerged from this collapse — the Weimar Republic — was born discredited in the eyes of many Germans: associated with defeat, with a humiliating peace treaty, and with political compromise. Its first five years, from 1918 to 1923, were a period in which the new democracy had to defend itself against armed revolts from both left and right, economic catastrophe, and the charge, repeated endlessly by nationalists, that the politicians who had signed the armistice were "November criminals" who had "stabbed the army in the back". This lesson examines how the Republic was founded, the settlement imposed at Versailles, the constitution designed at Weimar, and the cascading crises of 1919–23.
By late September 1918 General Erich Ludendorff privately admitted that the war could not be won. The German High Command, rather than accept responsibility, pressed the Kaiser to allow a civilian government to negotiate armistice terms — a deliberate move that would later make it easier for the army to blame politicians for defeat. Prince Max von Baden was appointed Chancellor on 3 October 1918. Within weeks, however, revolution had overtaken the orderly handover.
The trigger was a naval mutiny. On 28 October 1918, sailors at Wilhelmshaven refused orders for a final, suicidal sortie against the Royal Navy. The mutiny spread to the fleet at Kiel on 3 November. Workers' and soldiers' councils — Räte — sprang up across German cities, modelled loosely on the Russian soviets of 1917. On 9 November 1918, with Berlin effectively in revolutionary hands, Prince Max announced the Kaiser's abdication (before Wilhelm II had actually agreed) and handed power to Friedrich Ebert, leader of the Social Democratic Party (SPD).
That same afternoon, Scheidemann proclaimed a republic from the Reichstag to forestall a rival Communist declaration by Karl Liebknecht a few hours later from the Imperial Palace. Ebert formed a provisional Council of People's Representatives. Two days later, on 11 November 1918, the armistice was signed in a railway carriage at Compiègne. The fighting stopped at 11 a.m.
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| 29 September 1918 | Ludendorff tells Kaiser the war is lost |
| 3 October 1918 | Prince Max von Baden becomes Chancellor |
| 28 October 1918 | Naval mutiny at Wilhelmshaven |
| 3 November 1918 | Mutiny spreads to Kiel; workers' and soldiers' councils form |
| 9 November 1918 | Kaiser abdicates; republic proclaimed |
| 11 November 1918 | Armistice signed at Compiègne |
To keep order, Ebert agreed a pact with General Wilhelm Groener of the army on 10 November: the army would support the new government, and in return Ebert promised not to attempt radical reform of the officer corps. This Ebert–Groener Pact is crucial. It meant the Republic survived its first weeks, but it also bound the new democracy to an old-regime army that remained overwhelmingly hostile to it.
Elections for a Constituent Assembly were held on 19 January 1919. Fear of street violence in Berlin led the delegates to meet instead in the small town of Weimar — giving the Republic its name. The SPD won the largest share of the vote (38%); the Catholic Centre Party (Zentrum) and the liberal German Democratic Party (DDP) made up the "Weimar Coalition" that drafted the constitution, which came into force on 11 August 1919.
The constitution was ambitious and, in many respects, progressive for its time. All Germans aged 20 and above — men and women — could vote. Basic rights including freedom of speech, assembly and religion were guaranteed. Yet the constitution also contained compromises that would prove dangerous.
| Feature | Detail | Potential problem |
|---|---|---|
| Reichstag | Elected by proportional representation every 4 years | Many small parties; hard to form stable majority governments |
| President (Reichspräsident) | Elected every 7 years; head of state | Became a "substitute Kaiser" — especially under Hindenburg |
| Chancellor (Reichskanzler) | Head of government; appointed by President | Needed Reichstag majority — often collapsed |
| Article 48 | Allowed President to rule by emergency decree | Used repeatedly after 1930 to bypass parliament |
| Reichsrat | Upper house representing Länder (states) | Could delay but not block legislation |
| Universal suffrage | Men and women over 20 | Progressive; gave Nazis a mass electorate too |
Proportional representation meant that a party winning 5% of the vote received roughly 5% of Reichstag seats. In principle this was fair; in practice it produced highly fragmented parliaments and a succession of fragile coalition governments. Between 1919 and 1933 Germany had more than twenty different cabinets.
Article 48 became the constitution's most notorious clause. It gave the President the power, "in the case of a serious disturbance of public security and order", to suspend civil liberties and rule by emergency decree. Used cautiously by Ebert, it would be used to govern almost routinely from 1930 onwards — and, under Hitler in 1933, to dismantle the Republic itself.
The armistice was not a peace treaty. The peace was dictated — not negotiated — at the Paris Peace Conference and signed, under protest, by a German delegation in the Hall of Mirrors at Versailles on 28 June 1919. The German delegation was not permitted to take part in the discussions; it was presented with the final terms and told to sign. To nationalists this was a Diktat — a dictated peace — and the politicians who signed it were branded the "November criminals".
The terms shocked German opinion even though Germany itself had imposed harsher terms on Russia at Brest-Litovsk in 1918. They fell into four categories.
Article 231, the "war guilt clause", required Germany to accept sole responsibility for causing the war. This was the legal basis for reparations, but its moral sting was at least as important. Most Germans rejected the idea that their country alone had caused the war and resented being asked to sign a confession to that effect.
A Reparations Commission set the final figure in 1921 at 132 billion gold marks (roughly £6.6 billion at the time), payable in instalments over decades. Germany made the first payments, but the scale of the obligation became a permanent grievance and a driver of later economic crises.
Germany lost approximately 13% of its territory and around 12% of its population, as well as all of its overseas colonies.
| Territory | Outcome |
|---|---|
| Alsace-Lorraine | Returned to France |
| Saar coalfield | Placed under League of Nations control for 15 years (coal to France) |
| Eupen-Malmedy | Ceded to Belgium |
| Northern Schleswig | Ceded to Denmark after plebiscite |
| Polish Corridor and Posen | Ceded to Poland, giving it access to the Baltic |
| Danzig | Made a "Free City" under League of Nations supervision |
| Memelland | Ceded (later seized by Lithuania) |
| Overseas colonies | Redistributed as League of Nations mandates |
In addition, the Rhineland was demilitarised: Germany could not station troops or build fortifications west of the Rhine or within a 50 km strip east of it. Union with Austria (Anschluss) was forbidden.
| Restriction | Limit |
|---|---|
| Army | 100,000 men; no conscription |
| Navy | 15,000 sailors; 6 battleships; no submarines |
| Air force | None permitted |
| Tanks | None permitted |
| General Staff | Abolished |
For a country that had seen itself as Europe's premier military power, these limits were a humiliation. They also ensured a constant nationalist constituency demanding revision.
Exam Tip: For a "Explain why" 12-mark question on Versailles, do not simply list the terms. Link each term to a consequence — why war guilt damaged the Republic, why reparations mattered, why territorial loss fed nationalist politics. Examiners reward causal chains, not annotated maps.
Almost from its first day, the Weimar Republic was under attack from its political extremes.
The Spartacus League was a radical Marxist group led by Rosa Luxemburg and Karl Liebknecht. In December 1918 it renamed itself the Communist Party of Germany (KPD). On 5 January 1919, Spartacist militants attempted to seize key buildings in Berlin and declare a soviet-style republic. Ebert, without an army he could trust, turned to the Freikorps — units of demobilised soldiers, mostly right-wing nationalists, organised under former officers. The Freikorps crushed the uprising with considerable brutality. On 15 January 1919 Luxemburg and Liebknecht were captured, tortured and murdered by Freikorps men. The Republic had survived — but only by relying on armed formations that despised it.
In March 1920 the government ordered the disbanding of two Freikorps brigades. Their commanders refused and marched on Berlin, supported by Wolfgang Kapp, a right-wing civil servant. The regular army declined to intervene. General Hans von Seeckt reportedly said, "Reichswehr does not fire on Reichswehr." The government fled to Stuttgart but called on Berlin workers to resist. A general strike paralysed the capital; within four days the putsch collapsed. The episode exposed the army's unreliability and the depth of right-wing hostility to the Republic.
Between 1919 and 1922 there were more than 350 political assassinations in Germany. The great majority were carried out by the far right; the courts treated right-wing killers with striking leniency. The Foreign Minister Walther Rathenau — a liberal and a Jew — was machine-gunned in the street in June 1922 by members of the Organisation Consul.
These assaults drew energy from a powerful myth. The Dolchstosslegende — the "stab in the back" legend — held that the German army had never been defeated on the battlefield but had been betrayed by Jews, socialists and liberals on the home front. Paul von Hindenburg himself endorsed this version in testimony in 1919. It was historically false — the army had been beaten in the field by autumn 1918 — but its political usefulness was immense. It allowed nationalists to deny defeat and to treat the Republic and its founders as traitors.
flowchart TD
A[Defeat November 1918] --> B[Armistice signed by civilian government]
B --> C[Army spreads Dolchstoss myth]
C --> D["November criminals" narrative]
D --> E[Legitimacy crisis for Weimar]
A --> F[Treaty of Versailles]
F --> G[War guilt + reparations + territory]
G --> E
E --> H[Left and right attempts to overthrow Republic 1919-23]
The climax of the early crisis came in 1923. Germany had begun to fall behind on reparations payments, in part because the currency was already weakening. In January 1923 French and Belgian troops occupied the Ruhr, Germany's industrial heartland, to extract reparations in kind — coal, coke and steel — from the mines and factories.
The Weimar government, under Chancellor Wilhelm Cuno, called for passive resistance: Ruhr workers went on strike, and the government paid their wages. With no goods being produced and the state obligated to pay millions of idle workers, the government printed money. The mark, already weakening, entered a spiral.
| Month | Value of 1 US dollar in marks |
|---|---|
| January 1919 | ~9 |
| January 1922 | ~192 |
| January 1923 | ~18,000 |
| July 1923 | ~353,000 |
| November 1923 | ~4.2 trillion |
Hyperinflation wiped out the value of savings, pensions and fixed incomes. Wages were paid twice a day and spent immediately. Workers carried banknotes in wheelbarrows; children played with bundles of them as building blocks. Those with debts or physical assets (farmers, big industrialists) often benefited; those on fixed incomes — especially the Mittelstand (middle class) who had bought war bonds out of patriotism — were ruined. The trauma of 1923 shaped German attitudes to monetary policy for a century.
The crisis also emboldened extremists. In Munich, on 8 November 1923, Adolf Hitler and around 2,000 members of his National Socialist party attempted to seize control of the Bavarian government at a mass meeting in the Bürgerbräukeller, with the intention of marching on Berlin in imitation of Mussolini's 1922 March on Rome. The Munich Putsch failed the next morning: the Bavarian police opened fire in the Odeonsplatz, sixteen Nazis and four police officers were killed, and Hitler was arrested. He used his trial as a propaganda platform, received a lenient five-year sentence (of which he served less than one), and in Landsberg Prison began dictating Mein Kampf.
On the same afternoon that Hitler was arrested, a new Chancellor, Gustav Stresemann, ended passive resistance in the Ruhr and began the work of stabilising the currency. The worst of the crisis was over — though the Republic had nearly fallen.
Exam Tip: In a source question, evidence of suffering — a photograph of children playing with banknotes, a diary entry about a loaf of bread costing billions — is often used to infer attitudes rather than simply facts. Don't just say what a source shows; use it to support an inference about what ordinary Germans felt.
This content is aligned with the Edexcel GCSE History (1HI0) Paper 3 Modern Depth Study specification.