You are viewing a free preview of this lesson.
Subscribe to unlock all 9 lessons in this course and every other course on LearningBro.
Paper 2 Section B is the Poetry Anthology comparison question. It is worth 30 marks — the same as the 19th-century novel question — and it tests a very specific skill: comparison. You are given one named poem from your anthology cluster (printed on the paper) and must compare it with a second poem from the same cluster that you choose from memory. This lesson explains how to choose the second poem under time pressure, the two main comparative structures, the comparative connectives that signal comparison to the examiner, and the pitfalls that separate a Level 4 from a Level 6 response.
| Feature | Detail |
|---|---|
| Paper / Section | Paper 2, Section B |
| Marks | 30 marks |
| SPaG | None — SPaG only on Paper 1 Section A and Paper 2 Section A |
| Number of questions | ONE question only — no choice |
| Named poem | Printed on the exam paper |
| Comparison poem | YOU choose from the same cluster — closed book on your choice |
| Assessment Objectives | AO1, AO2, AO3 |
| Suggested time | Approximately 45 minutes (of Paper 2's 135 minutes) |
For the Power and Conflict cluster:
Compare how poets present [theme] in 'Exposure' and in one other poem from 'Power and Conflict'.
For the Love and Relationships cluster:
Compare the ways poets present [theme] in 'Neutral Tones' and in one other poem from 'Love and Relationships'.
The unique skill is comparison. The 30 marks do not just reward analysis of two poems — they reward comparative analysis: similarities, differences, and what the comparison reveals.
This is the single most time-sensitive decision in Paper 2. You have about 3 minutes to do it.
flowchart TD
A[Read question twice] --> B[Identify theme word]
B --> C[Read named poem]
C --> D["Recall comparison grid<br/>for named poem"]
D --> E{"Which 2-3 poems<br/>pair best?"}
E --> F["Check quotation memory<br/>for each candidate"]
F --> G["Pick poem with<br/>strongest coverage"]
G --> H[Commit and plan]
A comparison grid is your pre-exam prep for Section B. For each of the 15 poems, list 2–3 poems that pair well and why.
Example (Power and Conflict):
| Named poem | Strong pairings (and why) |
|---|---|
| Ozymandias | London (political power); Tissue (impermanence); My Last Duchess (pride and downfall) |
| Exposure | Bayonet Charge (war, nature's hostility); Remains (psychological cost) |
| Remains | War Photographer (psychological trauma); Kamikaze (memory and shame) |
| Poppies | War Photographer (distance from conflict); Kamikaze (family loss) |
| Kamikaze | Poppies (family loss); Remains (memory and shame) |
| My Last Duchess | Ozymandias (male power and control); Checking Out Me History (voice) |
| London | Ozymandias (political power); Tissue (human structures) |
| Tissue | Ozymandias (impermanence); London (human structures) |
Example (Love and Relationships):
| Named poem | Strong pairings (and why) |
|---|---|
| Neutral Tones | When We Two Parted (loss of love); Porphyria's Lover (troubled love) |
| Porphyria's Lover | My Last Duchess (control); Neutral Tones (troubled love) |
| Walking Away | Mother, Any Distance (parental letting go); Follower (parent-child) |
| Follower | Mother, Any Distance (parent-child); Walking Away (letting go) |
| Mother, Any Distance | Walking Away (letting go); Before You Were Mine (mother-child) |
| Before You Were Mine | Mother, Any Distance (mother-child); Eden Rock (memory) |
Building these grids is the single most valuable Paper 2 Section B prep you can do.
There are two main ways to structure a poetry comparison. Each has strengths.
Each paragraph compares both poems on a specific point.
Advantages:
Risks:
Analyse Poem 1 fully, then Poem 2 with constant links back to Poem 1.
Advantages:
Risks:
Exam Tip: Under exam conditions, the alternating method is almost always safer. It builds comparison into the DNA of your essay.
Comparison is a visible skill. The examiner needs to see it. Use comparative connectives at the start of sentences and paragraphs.
Owen's "Exposure" and Hughes's "Bayonet Charge" both present war as a conflict with nature rather than with the enemy. In Owen's poem, the speaker's torment is the cold — "the merciless iced east winds that knive us" — where the violent verb "knive" recasts wind as weapon and nature as aggressor. Hughes similarly weaponises landscape: the soldier in "Bayonet Charge" stumbles through a field where "the patriotic tear... turned into molten iron from the centre of his chest", the natural world and the body conspiring against him. Where Owen's hostile nature is stasis — a drawn-out waiting for cold to kill — Hughes's is kinesis: active, boiling, explosive. Both poets thus invert the pastoral tradition, but through contrasting temporal modes: Owen's frozen eternity, Hughes's frenzied second.
This paragraph compares in every sentence, uses multiple connectives, and highlights similarity and difference.
AO1 rewards:
AO2 rewards:
For anthology poetry, AO3 is often about ideas and themes rather than biography:
The most common AO3 failure in poetry comparison is turning context into biographical facts ("Simon Armitage was born in 1963"). Strong AO3 uses context to illuminate the poem's argument.
Subscribe to continue reading
Get full access to this lesson and all 9 lessons in this course.