You are viewing a free preview of this lesson.
Subscribe to unlock all 10 lessons in this course and every other course on LearningBro.
Edward I transformed English law more than any king since Henry II. His reign saw a flood of legislation that reformed criminal justice, land law, and local government. This lesson examines the medieval legal system and the key changes Edward introduced.
By the late 13th century, England had a well-developed legal system based on common law — law based on custom, precedent, and judicial decisions rather than written codes.
| Court | Jurisdiction | Who Presided |
|---|---|---|
| Manor courts | Disputes between tenants; minor offences; regulated farming practices | The lord of the manor or his steward |
| Hundred courts | Civil disputes and minor criminal cases within the hundred | The hundred bailiff |
| Shire (county) courts | More serious cases; land disputes; held monthly | The sheriff |
| Royal courts at Westminster | The most serious cases; appeals from lower courts; cases involving the king's rights | Royal justices |
| Eyre courts | Travelling courts that brought royal justice to the counties; heard all types of cases | Royal justices sent on circuit |
| Church courts | Cases involving clergy, marriage, wills, and moral offences | Bishops and church officials |
Key Term: The eyre (from the Latin iter, meaning journey) was a circuit of royal justices who travelled through the counties hearing cases. The eyre was both feared and respected — it brought the king's justice but also imposed heavy fines.
Medieval law enforcement was very different from today. There was no police force. Instead, the system relied on community responsibility.
| Method | Description |
|---|---|
| Tithings | Every male over 12 was required to belong to a group of 10 men (a tithing). Each tithing was collectively responsible for the behaviour of its members. |
| Hue and cry | If a crime was witnessed, the victim or witness was required to raise a "hue and cry" — shouting to alert the community. Everyone who heard was legally obliged to join the pursuit. |
| Sheriff | The king's representative in each county. Responsible for maintaining order, collecting taxes, and enforcing court decisions. |
| Posse comitatus | The sheriff could summon all able-bodied men in the county to pursue criminals. |
| Coroner | A royal officer responsible for investigating suspicious deaths and serious crimes. |
Medieval punishments were harsh by modern standards. They were designed to deter crime, punish offenders, and serve as public examples.
| Crime | Punishment |
|---|---|
| Petty theft | Stocks or pillory; public humiliation |
| Serious theft | Branding, mutilation (cutting off a hand or ear), or hanging |
| Murder | Hanging |
| Treason | Hanging, drawing, and quartering (for men); burning at the stake (for women) |
| Poaching in royal forests | Blinding, castration, or death (under the Forest Laws) |
| Debt | Imprisonment until the debt was paid |
Exam Tip: When writing about medieval punishments, always explain their purpose. They were not simply cruel — they served the practical functions of deterrence (frightening others from committing crimes), retribution (making the criminal suffer), and incapacitation (preventing the criminal from offending again through mutilation or death).
Edward I earned the title "the English Justinian" because of the sheer volume and importance of his legal reforms. His statutes (acts of Parliament) reshaped English law.
| Statute | Date | Key Provisions |
|---|---|---|
| Statute of Westminster I | 1275 | Reformed criminal law; required regular courts; restricted corruption among royal officials |
| Statute of Gloucester | 1278 | Launched the Quo Warranto inquiries — demanding lords prove their right to hold courts and collect revenues |
| Statute of Mortmain | 1279 | Forbade the granting of land to the Church without royal permission (to prevent land being removed from feudal obligations) |
| Statute of Acton Burnell | 1283 | Made it easier for merchants to recover debts; promoted trade |
| Statute of Westminster II | 1285 | Wide-ranging legal reforms including rules on land inheritance; introduced de donis conditionalibus (entailed estates that could not be broken up) |
| Statute of Winchester | 1285 | Reformed law enforcement: required every man to keep arms according to his wealth; strengthened the watch system in towns; required highways to be cleared of undergrowth (to prevent ambushes) |
| Statute of Quia Emptores | 1290 | Regulated the sale of land; prevented subinfeudation (the creation of new layers of feudal obligation) |
One of Edward's most important initiatives was the Quo Warranto inquiry (Latin for "by what warrant?"). Edward sent commissioners across England demanding that lords produce evidence of their right to hold courts, collect tolls, and exercise other privileges.
Many lords claimed their rights were based on ancient custom rather than a written charter. Edward's famous response to the Earl of Warenne, who waved a rusty sword and claimed his ancestors had won their rights at the Conquest, illustrated the tension between royal authority and baronial privilege.
The Quo Warranto inquiries asserted the principle that all rights ultimately derived from the king — a significant statement of royal authority.
Exam Tip: The Quo Warranto inquiries are a good example of how Edward used law as a tool of power. By demanding that lords prove their rights, he was asserting that the king was the source of all authority. This is a key theme of Edward's reign.
One of the darkest aspects of Edward's reign was the expulsion of England's Jewish community in 1290.
| Aspect | Detail |
|---|---|
| Background | Jews had been subjected to increasing restrictions, heavy taxation, and periodic violence throughout the 13th century |
| Edict of Expulsion | Issued on 18 July 1290; all Jews required to leave England by 1 November 1290 |
| Numbers affected | Approximately 3,000 Jews were expelled |
| Consequences | Jewish property was seized by the Crown; the Jewish community would not return to England until the 1650s |
Subscribe to continue reading
Get full access to this lesson and all 10 lessons in this course.