Constructing a Literary Argument

Writing well about literature is not simply about knowing the text — it is about constructing a clear, coherent argument that responds to the question and is supported by evidence. This lesson covers the essential skills of thesis writing, paragraph construction, quotation use, and analytical writing that you need for AQA A-Level English Literature.

---

The Thesis Statement

Every essay needs a thesis — a clear, arguable claim that answers the question and provides the direction for your entire essay.

Key Definition: Thesis statement — a concise statement, usually one or two sentences, that presents your central argument or interpretation in response to the essay question. It should be specific, arguable (not a statement of fact), and capable of being supported by textual evidence.

What Makes a Good Thesis?

Feature	Weak Thesis	Strong Thesis
Specific	"Shakespeare uses lots of imagery in Macbeth"	"Shakespeare's imagery of blood in Macbeth traces a trajectory from guilt to madness, as the physical stain becomes a psychological torment that neither Macbeth nor Lady Macbeth can escape"
Arguable	"Wuthering Heights is about love and revenge"	"In Wuthering Heights, Bronte presents love and revenge as inseparable forces, suggesting that Heathcliff's cruelty is not a corruption of his love for Catherine but an expression of it"
Answers the question	"The narrator is unreliable"	"Ishiguro uses Stevens's unreliable narration in The Remains of the Day to explore the psychological cost of emotional repression: Stevens's inability to tell his own story honestly mirrors his inability to live honestly"

How to Develop a Thesis

1. Read the question carefully — identify exactly what it is asking
2. Form an initial response — what is your instinctive answer?
3. Test it against the text — does the evidence support your response?
4. Refine and sharpen — make your thesis as precise and specific as possible
5. Consider counter-arguments — a strong thesis acknowledges complexity

Exam Tip: In a timed exam, spend the first five minutes planning your thesis. A clear thesis will guide your entire essay and prevent you from drifting into narrative retelling. Everything you write should serve your thesis.

---

Embedding Quotations

Quotations are the evidence that supports your argument. They must be embedded in your sentences — woven into the flow of your prose — rather than dropped in as isolated blocks.

How to Embed Quotations

Approach	Example
Embedded (correct)	Macbeth's description of his hands as making "the multitudinous seas incarnadine" reveals the overwhelming scale of his guilt — the blood is so potent it could transform the entire ocean.
Dropped in (weak)	Macbeth feels guilty. "Will all great Neptune's ocean wash this blood / Clean from my hand?" This shows his guilt.

Techniques for Embedding

1. Single words or short phrases — the most effective method. Pick out the most significant words and weave them into your sentence:

   • Hardy's description of Tess as a "pure woman" in the subtitle directly challenges Victorian moral judgements.

2. Partial quotations — use an ellipsis (...) to indicate omitted words if necessary:

   • The Ghost instructs Hamlet to "revenge his foul and most unnatural murder," establishing revenge as a filial duty.

3. Integrated longer quotations — use a colon to introduce a quotation that completes your sentence:

   • Lady Macbeth's command reveals her dominating will: "Look like th'innocent flower, / But be the serpent under't."

Common Mistakes to Avoid

Mistake	Why It's a Problem	Correction
Quotation without analysis	Evidence without interpretation is wasted	Always follow a quotation with analysis — what does it reveal?
Over-long quotations	Copying out large chunks suggests you cannot identify what is significant	Quote only the key words or phrases
Inaccurate quotation	Misquoting undermines your credibility	If unsure of the exact wording, paraphrase and note it
Quotation as sentence	Starting a sentence with a quotation often leads to grammatical awkwardness	Begin with your own words and weave the quotation in

---

Analytical Paragraphs: The PEAL Structure

A useful framework for constructing analytical paragraphs is PEAL: Point, Evidence, Analysis, Link.

Key Definition: PEAL — a paragraph structure consisting of a Point (your argument), Evidence (a quotation or reference), Analysis (exploration of the evidence's language, form, and meaning), and Link (connection back to the question or thesis).

PEAL in Practice

Question: How does Shakespeare present guilt in Macbeth?

Point: Shakespeare presents guilt as an inescapable physical sensation that overwhelms rational thought.