You are viewing a free preview of this lesson.
Subscribe to unlock all 10 lessons in this course and every other course on LearningBro.
The Protestant Reformation of the sixteenth century was the most seismic event in Western Christianity since the early councils. It shattered the institutional unity of the Western Church, produced new confessional traditions — Lutheran, Reformed and Anglican — and provoked a vigorous Catholic response known as the Counter-Reformation. The issues at stake — how a sinner is made right with God, where authority in the Church finally lies, and what the Church and its sacraments are for — remain central to Christian identity, and they bear directly on the AQA Christianity topics of justification, authority and the sources of wisdom.
By the early sixteenth century, dissatisfaction with the institutional Church had been building for generations:
It is important not to caricature the late-medieval Church as simply corrupt and ripe for collapse. Popular religion was vigorous, and many were sincerely devout. But the combination of real abuses, a heightened anxiety about sin and salvation, the new intellectual currents of humanism, the technology of print, and the political ambitions of rulers created conditions in which a theological spark could ignite a continent-wide conflagration.
The political dimension deserves particular emphasis, because it helps explain why Luther succeeded where earlier reformers such as Hus had failed. The Holy Roman Empire was a patchwork of semi-independent territories, and many German princes had their own reasons — resentment of papal taxation, desire for Church lands, assertion of local autonomy against both pope and emperor — to support a reform that weakened Rome's grip. There was also a current of German national feeling against what was perceived as an Italian-dominated papacy that drained German wealth. When the Emperor Charles V, a devout Catholic preoccupied with wars against France and the Ottoman Turks, was unable to suppress the movement in its critical early years, the Reformation gained the time and the political protection it needed to become established. The interplay of religious conviction and political opportunity is therefore written into the Reformation from the very beginning, and it is a central theme for evaluative essays on whether the movement was primarily theological or primarily political.
The Reformation is conventionally dated to 31 October 1517, when Martin Luther — an Augustinian friar and professor of theology at the University of Wittenberg — is said to have posted his Ninety-Five Theses on the door of the Castle Church. (Whether the posting literally happened is debated by historians; what is certain is that Luther circulated the theses, and that they spread rapidly with the help of the printing press.) The theses were academic propositions for debate in Latin, directed primarily against the theology and abuse of indulgences. They did not yet contain Luther's developed doctrine of justification, and Luther did not at first intend to break with Rome; he sought reform from within. But the controversy escalated quickly. Summoned to defend himself, pressed in debate by the theologian Johann Eck at Leipzig (1519) into conceding that both popes and councils could err, and increasingly convinced that the papacy itself was the obstacle to the gospel, Luther was driven step by step toward a more radical position, until reconciliation became impossible.
Luther's decisive breakthrough was theological and deeply personal. Tormented by the question of how a sinner could ever stand before a righteous God, he found release in his study of Paul. Reflecting on Romans 1:17 — "the righteous shall live by faith" (itself quoting Habakkuk 2:4) — Luther came to see that the "righteousness of God" is not a standard God demands and we fail to meet, but a gift God gives. His theology crystallised around several principles, later summarised as the solas:
Key term: Justification by faith alone (sola fide) — the Reformation teaching that a sinner is declared righteous before God solely through faith in Christ, whose righteousness is credited (imputed) to the believer, and not on the basis of human works or merit.
Luther was excommunicated by Leo X in 1521 and summoned before the Emperor Charles V at the Diet of Worms (April 1521). Ordered to recant, he refused, declaring that his conscience was captive to the Word of God; tradition reports his words as "Here I stand; I can do no other." Sheltered by Frederick of Saxony, he translated the New Testament into German, a landmark in both religion and the German language.
The doctrine of justification — how a sinner is made or declared right with God — was, in Luther's words, the article by which the Church stands or falls. The dispute between Protestant and Catholic on this point repays careful attention, because it is precisely the issue the AQA specification raises under Christian teaching on good conduct and salvation.
For Luther and the Reformers, justification is forensic and by imputation: God declares the sinner righteous, crediting to them the righteousness of Christ received by faith, even though the sinner remains in themselves imperfect. Luther captured this with the formula that the Christian is simul iustus et peccator — "at once righteous and a sinner": righteous in God's verdict through Christ, yet still a sinner in actual condition. Justification, on this view, is an event, a once-for-all change of status before God, received by faith alone and prior to any good works; good works then follow as the fruit and evidence of faith, not as its cause. The believer is freed from anxious striving to earn salvation and serves God out of gratitude rather than fear.
For the Catholic tradition, classically defined at Trent, justification is not merely a change of status but a real transformation of the person: grace is infused into the soul, making the person actually righteous, and the believer genuinely cooperates with grace, so that good works done in grace are truly meritorious and contribute to final salvation. On this view justification is a process of growth in holiness, not a single declarative act, and faith must be "formed by love" (fides caritate formata) to justify.
The disagreement is subtle but profound. Both sides affirm the necessity of grace and reject the Pelagian idea that we save ourselves; the question is whether righteousness is imputed (credited from outside) or imparted (infused within), and whether human cooperation and merit have any place. So central was this dispute that it divided Western Christendom for centuries, though it is worth noting that modern ecumenical dialogue — notably the 1999 Joint Declaration on the Doctrine of Justification between the Roman Catholic Church and the Lutheran World Federation — has found a surprising measure of convergence, suggesting the sixteenth-century formulations may have talked past each other more than was once thought.
Key term: Justification by imputation — the Protestant teaching that God credits (imputes) the righteousness of Christ to the believer, declaring them righteous, as distinct from the Catholic view that grace is infused to make the believer actually righteous.
John Calvin, a French lawyer turned theologian, became the most systematic of the second-generation Reformers. His Institutes of the Christian Religion (first edition 1536, definitive edition 1559) is the most comprehensive statement of Reformed theology. Its central elements include:
Calvin's Geneva became a model Reformed city, governed in close partnership between the magistrates and the Church's consistory, which exercised moral discipline over the community. Geneva trained Protestant pastors from across Europe and earned the title "the Protestant Rome". The Genevan model spread widely: the Reformed (Calvinist) tradition shaped the Presbyterian Church of Scotland under John Knox, the Huguenots of France, the Dutch Reformed Church, and the Puritans of England and New England, making Calvinism one of the most internationally influential forms of Protestantism.
Calvin's doctrine of double predestination has always been the most controversial element of his thought. It follows rigorously from his premises: if salvation is wholly God's work and human beings can contribute nothing, then the difference between the saved and the lost must lie entirely in God's eternal choice. Calvin did not shrink from the conclusion that God ordains the reprobate to condemnation, though he called it a "dreadful decree" (decretum horribile) — not meaning that it is monstrous, but that it is awe-inspiring and not to be contemplated lightly. Defenders argue that the doctrine magnifies the sovereignty and grace of God and removes all ground for human boasting; critics — from Calvin's own day to the present — protest that it appears to make God the author of evil, to condemn people for what they cannot avoid, and to undermine any meaningful human freedom. The doctrine directly revives the Augustine–Pelagius dispute, with Calvin pressing the Augustinian logic to its furthest point. It was precisely against this teaching that Jacobus Arminius (1560–1609) reacted, holding that grace is genuinely offered to all and may be resisted — a position that would divide the Reformed world at the Synod of Dort (1618–19).
Key term: Predestination — the doctrine that God has determined from eternity the ultimate destiny of human beings. In its "double" form (Calvin), God ordains both the elect to salvation and the reprobate to condemnation; "single" predestination affirms God's election of the saved while leaving the fate of the rest to their own sin.
The English Reformation followed a distinctive and turbulent course. Under Henry VIII the break with Rome was largely jurisdictional — Henry remained conservative in doctrine — but it was accompanied by the momentous Dissolution of the Monasteries (1536–1541), which redistributed vast monastic wealth and ended the thousand-year-old institution of English monasticism. Under his son Edward VI the Church moved in a decisively Protestant direction, with Cranmer's English Prayer Books of 1549 and 1552. Under Mary I (1553–1558) the country was briefly and forcibly returned to Catholicism, with the burning of Protestants including Cranmer himself. Finally, the Elizabethan Settlement (from 1559) established the enduring shape of the Church of England as a national, Protestant Church that nonetheless retained bishops, much traditional liturgy and ceremony, and a deliberately broad, comprehensive character — the famous via media. This compromise left tensions unresolved, producing both the Puritan movement (pressing for further reform) and, much later, the Anglo-Catholic revival; and it is the background to live contemporary issues such as the ordination of women, which the Church of England approved in 1992 (with the first ordinations in 1994) and extended to the episcopate in 2014.
No single issue divided the Reformers among themselves more sharply than the Eucharist (the Lord's Supper, Holy Communion), and the differences map a genuine theological spectrum that the AQA student should be able to set out:
Subscribe to continue reading
Get full access to this lesson and all 10 lessons in this course.