You are viewing a free preview of this lesson.
Subscribe to unlock all 10 lessons in this course and every other course on LearningBro.
The story of the United States between 1955 and 1992 is, in one telling, the story of a great arc: from the confident, conformist liberalism of the affluent 1950s, through the challenges and upheavals of the 1960s, to the disillusionment of the 1970s, and finally to the conservative revival that closes the period. The election of Ronald Reagan in 1980 marked the culmination of a movement that had been building for a generation — the American conservative movement, or New Right — and it inaugurated a decade in which the terms of American politics were decisively shifted rightward. Reagan promised to restore the confidence and greatness that Vietnam, Watergate, and the "malaise" of the 1970s had drained away; to cut taxes, shrink government, and revive the economy; to reassert American strength against the Soviet Union; and to champion traditional values against the social changes of the previous decades. This lesson examines the rise of the New Right, Reagan's election and his economic programme of "Reaganomics," the deregulation and the culture wars of the 1980s, the extraordinary end of the Cold War, and the presidency of George H. W. Bush to 1992.
For the Edexcel depth study, the Reagan era is the resolution of the whole period's central theme — the tension between conformity and challenge — in favour of a conservative reaction that drew on the disillusionment of the 1970s and on the backlash against the challenges of the 1960s. It is essential to grasp that the conservative revival was not simply a rejection of the preceding decades but their product: it fed on the anti-war backlash, the reaction against the counterculture and the women's movement, the collapse of trust in liberal government after Vietnam and Watergate, and the failure of Keynesian economics amid stagflation. Mastery of this topic depends on assessing Reagan's record with balance — the genuine economic revival and the widening inequality, the restoration of national confidence and the vast deficits, the role in ending the Cold War and the debate over how large that role truly was. As with the rest of the option, the subject must be handled with rigour and even-handedness: these remain contested questions, and the strongest analysis presents the achievements and the criticisms of the Reagan era as historical matters to be weighed, not causes to be pleaded.
By the end of this lesson you will be able to:
This lesson concludes the teaching of Edexcel 9HI0 Paper 2, Option 2H.2 (Route H depth study): "The USA, 1955–92: conformity and challenge." It covers the rise of the New Right, the election of Reagan (1980), Reaganomics and deregulation, the culture wars, the end of the Cold War, and the Bush presidency to 1992. Within our own teaching sequence it is placed last as the resolution of the period's arc — the conservative reaction that grew from the disillusionment of the Nixon–Ford–Carter years and brought the challenges of the 1960s to their political reckoning.
Because Paper 2 is a depth paper, the reward is for fine command of a short period and for source judgements set firmly in context. (For the precise weightings and question wording, consult the official Edexcel specification and sample assessment materials rather than any paraphrase.)
Key definition. The New Right refers to the broad conservative coalition that rose to dominance in American politics from the 1970s, fusing three distinct strands: economic conservatives favouring low taxes, free markets, and deregulation; the religious right, mobilised around "traditional values" and social issues such as abortion; and Cold War hawks demanding a more assertive stand against the Soviet Union. Its capture of the Republican Party and its victory in 1980 form the political climax of this course.
The conservative triumph of 1980 was the product of a long march, not a sudden turn. Understanding its origins is essential, for the strongest answers treat Reagan's victory as the culmination of forces that had been gathering since the 1960s rather than as a personal or accidental success. Several distinct strands converged.
The reaction against the 1960s. The conservative revival fed directly on the backlash against the upheavals of the previous decades — the anti-war protests, the counterculture, urban unrest, rising crime, and the perceived permissiveness of the age. Nixon's mobilisation of the "silent majority," examined in the previous lesson, had already shown the political potency of this reaction, and it supplied conservatism with a large and receptive constituency of Americans who felt that the country had lost its bearings.
The religious right. Perhaps the most striking new element was the political mobilisation of conservative Protestants, especially evangelicals, who had largely stood aloof from politics. Galvanised above all by the social changes of the 1960s and 1970s — Roe v. Wade (1973), the campaign for the Equal Rights Amendment, the changing place of women and the family, and the broader liberalisation of morals examined in the women's movement lesson — they organised into a formidable political force. Organisations such as the Moral Majority, founded by the preacher Jerry Falwell in 1979, brought millions of religious conservatives into the Republican coalition around the "social issues," a realignment of enduring importance.
Economic conservatism. The intellectual case for free markets, low taxes, and a smaller state, long marginal, gained new authority as stagflation discredited the Keynesian orthodoxy of the liberal era. The ideas of economists associated with free-market thought, popularised through think tanks and the business community, offered an alternative to the seemingly exhausted managed economy — and a tax revolt, symbolised by California's Proposition 13 of 1978, showed the political appeal of tax-cutting.
Cold War hawks. A third strand rejected the détente of the Nixon and Carter years as weakness and demanded a rearmed, assertive America to confront the Soviet Union — a stance given fresh urgency by the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan (1979) and the humiliation of the Iran hostage crisis.
The movement had found an earlier champion in Barry Goldwater, whose landslide defeat in the 1964 presidential election had seemed to bury conservatism but in fact planted its seeds; and its ideas were carried forward by activists, publications, and a growing network of institutions through the 1960s and 1970s. In Ronald Reagan — a former actor and Governor of California, an eloquent and genial communicator who had campaigned for Goldwater — the movement found the leader who could unite its strands and carry them to national power. The historian Sean Wilentz, in The Age of Reagan (2008), argued that Reagan so dominated the politics of his era that the years from the 1970s to the early twenty-first century can meaningfully be called an age bearing his name — a measure of how decisively the conservative revival reset the terms of American political life.
Reagan won the presidency in 1980, decisively defeating the incumbent Jimmy Carter against the backdrop of stagflation, the energy crisis, and the unresolved Iran hostage crisis that had come to symbolise national impotence. His campaign fused the strands of the New Right into a single, optimistic appeal: tax cuts and a smaller federal government to revive the economy and restore individual freedom; a military build-up and a harder line to reassert American strength abroad; and a defence of traditional values that spoke to the religious right. Above all, against the "malaise" of the Carter years, Reagan offered a message of renewed confidence and national pride — the promise of "morning again in America" — that answered the disillusionment of the 1970s directly.
Reagan's political gifts were central to his success and are worth analysing. His sunny optimism, his mastery of television, and his ability to communicate a few simple, powerful themes earned him the label "the Great Communicator" and allowed him to build a broad electoral coalition. It included traditional Republicans, Cold War hawks, and the religious right, but crucially it also drew in the "Reagan Democrats" — white working-class and Catholic voters, many of them in the industrial North, who had been alienated from a Democratic Party they associated with the disorder, permissiveness, and failures of the previous decades. This coalition realigned American politics and gave Reagan a landslide re-election in 1984.
The centrepiece of Reagan's domestic programme was the economic strategy that came to be called "Reaganomics" — an attempt to reverse the stagflation of the 1970s and to shrink the role of the federal government in the economy. Its logic rested on the conviction, drawn from free-market and "supply-side" economics, that the way to revive growth was not to manage demand from above but to unleash the productive energies of businesses and individuals by cutting taxes and freeing them from regulation.
Reaganomics rested on four pillars:
| Pillar | Policy | Intended effect |
|---|---|---|
| Tax cuts | Large reductions in income tax rates, especially at the top, on "supply-side" reasoning | To incentivise work, saving, and investment, and so revive growth |
| Deregulation | Rolling back federal regulation of industry, finance, and the environment | To free businesses to invest and compete |
| Spending restraint | Cuts to domestic welfare and social programmes | To shrink government and curb the deficit |
| Monetary discipline | Support for the tight-money, high-interest policy used to crush inflation | To break the inflationary spiral of the 1970s |
The results were mixed and remain contested, and a balanced assessment must weigh them against one another. On the positive side, the punishing inflation of the 1970s was broken — largely by the tight monetary policy of the Federal Reserve, at the cost of a severe recession in the early 1980s — and after that recession the economy entered a long expansion, with strong growth, falling inflation, and rising employment through the middle and later years of the decade. Reagan's supporters credited his programme with restoring American prosperity and confidence.
The criticisms are equally substantial. First, the promised balancing of the budget did not occur: the combination of deep tax cuts with a vast military build-up produced the largest peacetime budget deficits in American history to that point, and the national debt roughly tripled over the decade, transforming the United States from the world's largest creditor into its largest debtor. The "supply-side" claim that tax cuts would pay for themselves through growth was not borne out. Second, the benefits of the expansion were distributed very unequally: inequality widened markedly, with the largest gains flowing to the wealthiest Americans while poverty persisted and the real position of many lower-income and industrial workers stagnated or declined amid the decline of manufacturing. Critics spoke of a decade of conspicuous wealth at the top and hardship below. The historian Sean Wilentz and others have emphasised precisely this double-edged character of the Reagan boom — a genuine revival that nonetheless deepened the divide between rich and poor and left a legacy of debt.
Beyond tax policy, the Reagan administration pursued a broad programme of deregulation and a rhetorical assault on the very idea of activist government — Reagan's famous formulation held that government was not the solution to the nation's problems but the problem itself. Federal regulation of industry, finance, energy, and the environment was rolled back or weakened; the enforcement of anti-trust and environmental rules was relaxed; and the administration took a markedly hostile stance toward organised labour, dramatised early on by Reagan's dismissal of striking federal air-traffic controllers in 1981, which signalled a decisive shift in the balance between employers and unions.
The consequences were, again, double-edged. Supporters argued that deregulation freed the economy and spurred innovation and growth. Critics pointed to the costs: the weakening of environmental and consumer protections, the erosion of union strength and with it of working-class bargaining power, and — most damagingly — the role of financial deregulation in the savings and loan crisis, a wave of failures among deregulated thrift institutions that required an enormous taxpayer-funded bailout by the end of the decade. Moreover, the reality of "small government" was more rhetorical than actual: while domestic programmes were cut, overall federal spending rose, driven by the military build-up, and the size of the deficit meant that the state remained very large indeed. What changed most durably was not the size of government but the terms of debate — the presumption, which outlasted Reagan and reshaped even the Democratic Party, that markets were to be trusted and government distrusted.
The 1980s saw the social conflicts opened by the challenges of the 1960s and 1970s harden into the enduring culture wars — the bitter contest over abortion, religion, sexuality, family, and national values that has divided American politics ever since. The mobilisation of the religious right, examined above, brought these "social issues" to the centre of national politics, and the Reagan coalition depended upon them.
Abortion was the most intense battleground. The pro-life movement galvanised by Roe v. Wade (1973) became a pillar of the conservative coalition, and the composition of the Supreme Court — to which Reagan made several appointments, including the first woman, Sandra Day O'Connor — became a central political stake precisely because of the hope, or fear, that Roe might be overturned. Religion in public life, prayer in schools, and the teaching of evolution were fought over. The changing place of women and the family remained contested, the defeat of the Equal Rights Amendment in the early 1980s marking a victory for the conservative side.
The AIDS epidemic, which emerged in the early 1980s and took a devastating toll, became entangled with the culture wars in painful ways. The disease struck first and hardest at the gay community, and the administration's response was widely criticised as slow and inadequate; the crisis at once galvanised gay activism and hardened conservative hostility, making it one of the most charged episodes of the decade. Questions of race also ran through the culture wars, as conservatives challenged affirmative action and the legacy of the Great Society, and debates over welfare, crime, and the inner cities took on a racial charge. The essential analytical point is that the culture wars of the 1980s were the direct continuation of the challenges of the earlier lessons: the conservative revival was, in large part, the political reaction to the social transformations of the 1960s and 1970s, fought out over the same questions of gender, sexuality, religion, and race.
The most momentous development of the Reagan years unfolded on the world stage: the winding down and, by the early 1990s, the end of the Cold War that had shaped American life since the 1940s. Reagan's approach passed through two contrasting phases, and the relationship between them is central to any assessment of his role.
In his first term, Reagan pursued a policy of confrontation. He denounced the Soviet Union in stark moral terms — famously as an "evil empire" — and launched the largest peacetime military build-up in American history, including the Strategic Defense Initiative (dubbed "Star Wars" by its critics), a proposed space-based missile-defence system. The aim, his supporters argued, was to negotiate from strength and to strain the faltering Soviet economy in an arms race it could not sustain.
In his second term, confrontation gave way to remarkable diplomacy. The accession of the reformist Soviet leader Mikhail Gorbachev in 1985, with his programmes of glasnost (openness) and perestroika (restructuring), transformed the possibilities, and Reagan proved willing to negotiate. A series of summits produced, in 1987, the Intermediate-Range Nuclear Forces (INF) Treaty, the first agreement to abolish an entire class of nuclear weapons. By the time Reagan left office, the Cold War was visibly thawing; the revolutions of 1989 swept away communism in Eastern Europe, the Berlin Wall fell, and by the end of 1991 the Soviet Union itself had dissolved — during the presidency of Reagan's successor.
Subscribe to continue reading
Get full access to this lesson and all 10 lessons in this course.