You are viewing a free preview of this lesson.
Subscribe to unlock all 13 lessons in this course and every other course on LearningBro.
Paper 3 is the most distinctive paper in the Edexcel B GCSE Geography exam. It is worth 25% of your total grade (64 marks in 1 hour 30 minutes) and is based on a pre-released resource booklet that you receive 12 weeks before the exam. This paper tests your ability to interpret geographical information, analyse competing viewpoints, and make a justified decision — skills that are fundamental to being a good geographer.
Many students find Paper 3 challenging because it feels different from the other papers. However, with the right preparation, it can actually be the paper where you score most confidently, because you know what the resources contain before you enter the exam room.
The resource booklet is a collection of 8–12 resources related to a geographical issue or decision. It might focus on topics such as:
| Resource Type | Examples |
|---|---|
| Maps | OS maps, thematic maps, GIS maps, location maps |
| Data | Tables, graphs, statistics about the area |
| Photographs | Ground-level, aerial or satellite images |
| Stakeholder views | Quotes from residents, businesses, environmental groups, councils |
| Text extracts | News articles, reports, government plans |
| Diagrams | Process diagrams, cross-sections, plans of proposed developments |
You receive the booklet 12 weeks before the exam. This is a significant advantage — use it.
| Stage | When | What to Do |
|---|---|---|
| First read | Week 1 | Read through all resources. Identify the geographical issue and the key question being asked |
| Deep analysis | Weeks 2–4 | Annotate each resource. Highlight key data. Note what each stakeholder wants and why |
| Background research | Weeks 3–6 | Research the location and topic. Find additional context that is not in the booklet |
| Practice questions | Weeks 6–10 | Ask yourself: What questions might the examiner ask? What data supports different decisions? |
| Final review | Weeks 10–12 | Revise your annotations. Practise writing decision-making answers under timed conditions |
Exam Tip: You cannot bring your annotated booklet into the exam. A clean copy is provided. But the 12 weeks of preparation mean you should know the resources so well that you barely need to re-read them. Focus on remembering key data points, stakeholder positions, and the geographical processes involved.
For each resource, identify:
| Annotation | Question to Ask | Example |
|---|---|---|
| What does it show? | What information does this resource provide? | "Figure 3 shows population growth projections for the next 20 years" |
| Key data | What are the most important numbers or facts? | "Population expected to grow by 35% from 45,000 to 61,000 by 2040" |
| Who benefits? | Which stakeholders would use this data to support their view? | "Developers would use this to argue that more housing is needed" |
| Limitations | What does this resource NOT show? | "Does not show where the new population would live or their income levels" |
| Links to other resources | How does this connect to other resources in the booklet? | "Links to Figure 5 which shows available development sites" |
One of the most important preparation tasks is identifying and understanding the stakeholders — the people and groups with an interest in the decision.
| Stakeholder | Typical Priority | Likely Position |
|---|---|---|
| Local residents | Quality of life, property values, services | May oppose development that increases traffic or reduces green space |
| Developers / businesses | Profit, employment, growth | Favour development that generates economic activity |
| Local council | Housing need, economic growth, voter satisfaction | Must balance competing demands; seek compromise |
| Environmental groups | Wildlife, habitats, sustainability | Oppose development on sensitive sites; favour green solutions |
| Farmers / landowners | Land value, livelihood | May favour selling land for development; may oppose if farming is threatened |
| Young people | Housing affordability, jobs | Favour development that creates homes and employment |
| Transport authorities | Road capacity, public transport | Concerned about traffic congestion from new development |
flowchart TD
A["STAKEHOLDER ANALYSIS"] --> B["Identify ALL stakeholders"]
B --> C["What does each want?"]
C --> D["What evidence supports<br/>their position?"]
D --> E["What are the strengths and<br/>weaknesses of their argument?"]
E --> F["Whose interests should<br/>take priority and WHY?"]
The final question on Paper 3 is the decision-making question, typically worth 12+ marks. It asks you to make a choice and justify it.
| Section | What to Write | Marks Focus |
|---|---|---|
| Introduction | State the decision clearly. Outline the options available | AO1 — knowledge |
| Arguments for your choice | Use evidence from the resource booklet to support your decision | AO2 — application and analysis |
| Arguments against alternatives | Explain why you rejected the other options | AO2 — evaluation |
| Stakeholder impact | Consider who benefits and who loses from your decision | AO2 — evaluation |
| Sustainability | Consider long-term economic, social and environmental impacts | AO2 — evaluation |
| Conclusion | Restate your decision with a strong justification | AO2 — judgement |
There is no single correct answer. The examiner is assessing:
| What They Assess | What Scores Highly |
|---|---|
| Quality of argument | Well-structured, logical, balanced |
| Use of evidence | Specific data from the resource booklet, not vague generalisations |
| Range of factors considered | Economic, social, environmental, political |
| Stakeholder awareness | Considers multiple perspectives |
| Justified judgement | Clear decision with reasons that outweigh the counter-arguments |
| Communication | Clear paragraphs, correct terminology, good SPaG |
Exam Tip: Choose the option you can argue for most strongly, not necessarily the one you personally agree with. If Option A has better data support in the resource booklet than Option B, choose Option A even if you personally prefer Option B. The exam rewards the quality of your argument, not the option itself.
A key skill for Paper 3 is weighing evidence — deciding which arguments are strongest.
| Factor | Higher Weight | Lower Weight |
|---|---|---|
| Data quality | Statistical evidence from reliable sources | Opinions without data support |
| Scale of impact | Affects many people or large areas | Affects few people or small areas |
| Reversibility | Irreversible damage (destroying a habitat) | Reversible impact (temporary noise) |
| Duration | Long-term or permanent impact | Short-term or temporary impact |
| Alternatives | No alternative available | Other options exist |
| Weight | Phrases |
|---|---|
| Strongly supports | "The data clearly shows that...", "There is strong evidence that..." |
| Partially supports | "To some extent, the evidence suggests...", "While there is evidence for..., this must be balanced against..." |
| Weakly supports | "Although [stakeholder] argues that..., the data does not fully support this claim" |
| Undermines | "This argument is weakened by the fact that...", "The data contradicts this view because..." |
Question: "Using the resource booklet, decide whether the new housing development should be built on Site A (greenfield) or Site B (brownfield). Justify your decision." (12 marks + 4 SPaG)
Answer plan:
| Section | Content |
|---|---|
| Decision | Site B (brownfield) |
| For Site B | Brownfield — reduces urban sprawl; existing infrastructure; regenerates derelict area; closer to services |
| Evidence | Figure 4 shows Site B has road and rail links already; Table 2 shows 60% of residents want the brownfield option |
| Against Site A | Greenfield — destroys wildlife habitat (Figure 6 shows protected species); increased traffic on rural roads (Figure 7) |
| Stakeholders | Residents benefit from regeneration; environmental groups relieved; farmers retain their land |
| Sustainability | More sustainable — less car dependency, reuses previously developed land, reduces carbon footprint |
| Conclusion | Site B is the stronger option because it balances housing need with environmental protection and has majority public support |
Paper 3 allocates 4 marks for SPaG within the decision-making question. To maximise these:
| Area | Technique |
|---|---|
| Spelling | Spell key geographical terms correctly (sustainability, environment, infrastructure, development) |
| Punctuation | Use full stops and commas correctly; use paragraphs to separate points |
| Grammar | Write in complete, grammatically correct sentences |
| Vocabulary | Use geographical terminology appropriately and precisely |
| Structure | Organise your answer in clear, logical paragraphs |
Subscribe to continue reading
Get full access to this lesson and all 13 lessons in this course.